By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - General Discussion - Mafia Round 14 - Game Thread

KingFate on 10 March 2010

Well seeing as dsister says Falcon is the only known mafia, and it seems people are somewhat on the fence on whom to vote for.
Vote:Falcon095



PSN ID: KingFate_

Around the Network
c03n3nj0 on 10 March 2010
trangentspree said:
c03n3nj0 said:
trangentspree said:
c03n3nj0 said:
trangentspree said:
c03n3nj0 said:

I will Vote- Tangentspree

Why? I know for a fact that he's lying. And I want to double lynch Falcon095, with him. 

This put me in a disadvantage, though, 'cause tangent came up with awesome reasons all of a sudden. 

 

Why are you saying that you know for a fact I'm lying? Are trying to claim that you are the nurse???

Yep. 

I would've believed for a second that Truck may have put two nurses in, but the way you roleclaimed is way too scummy. 

And besides, a protective role would try to stay low as long as possible, you just went up and roleclaimed nurse as an excuse for lynching WoW. 

 

@ How could you believe for a second that Truck would put two nurses in the same game? That would be monstrously out of balance.

@ I had been following WoW carefully the whole game ever since he started demanding Doctor protection and then claiming he got it on the first night.

@ Well, thank you for proving my point. You're lying. >:D

@ That is why I said I may have believed it, it made some sense. But, how could you have known if she got it or not? And besides, we told you it wasn't out of the norm. And the final roleclaim seems like a final attempt to save your butt from suspicion. 

There is no way there could be two nurses in this game. No. Way. And I never said that I did know. I only said I didn't like that he was claiming that he did. This is a bullish lie on your part because after finding out Falcon is mafia and with my roleclaim, you knew you had no where to hide.

We didn't find out that WoW did get protection from the doctor on the first night until we found out that Arkzero was the doctor.


I should've worded that better, I wasn't accusing you of thinking that, it was a rhetorical question... or something along those lines.

Anyways, tell me, why did you choose to roleclaim nurse int he first place? You felt threatened? What I can't wrap my head around was that it doesn't make sense, besides trying to clear your name fromt he Wow mislynch.



 Tag (Courtesy of Fkusumot) "If I'm posting in this thread then it's probally a spam thread."                               

trangentspree on 10 March 2010
c03n3nj0 said:
trangentspree said:
c03n3nj0 said:
trangentspree said:
c03n3nj0 said:
trangentspree said:
c03n3nj0 said:

I will Vote- Tangentspree

Why? I know for a fact that he's lying. And I want to double lynch Falcon095, with him. 

This put me in a disadvantage, though, 'cause tangent came up with awesome reasons all of a sudden. 

 

Why are you saying that you know for a fact I'm lying? Are trying to claim that you are the nurse???

Yep. 

I would've believed for a second that Truck may have put two nurses in, but the way you roleclaimed is way too scummy. 

And besides, a protective role would try to stay low as long as possible, you just went up and roleclaimed nurse as an excuse for lynching WoW. 

 

@ How could you believe for a second that Truck would put two nurses in the same game? That would be monstrously out of balance.

@ I had been following WoW carefully the whole game ever since he started demanding Doctor protection and then claiming he got it on the first night.

@ Well, thank you for proving my point. You're lying. >:D

@ That is why I said I may have believed it, it made some sense. But, how could you have known if she got it or not? And besides, we told you it wasn't out of the norm. And the final roleclaim seems like a final attempt to save your butt from suspicion. 

There is no way there could be two nurses in this game. No. Way. And I never said that I did know. I only said I didn't like that he was claiming that he did. This is a bullish lie on your part because after finding out Falcon is mafia and with my roleclaim, you knew you had no where to hide.

We didn't find out that WoW did get protection from the doctor on the first night until we found out that Arkzero was the doctor.


I should've worded that better, I wasn't accusing you of thinking that, it was a rhetorical question... or something along those lines.

Anyways, tell me, why did you choose to roleclaim nurse int he first place? You felt threatened? What I can't wrap my head around was that it doesn't make sense, besides trying to clear your name fromt he Wow mislynch.

This could be the final day j0.

We still have a serial killer at large and I can't tell if Falcon is the last mafia or not, at this stage it's useful to know who people actually are. And my roleclaiming is a no-lose scenario now, I can still protect disister one more night if I get targetted. If we get one more day that is. That means dsister will go through to the next day and will be able to carry out an investigation if needs be.

I don't understand why you seem to be backing down now. I refuse to believe there could be two nurses in this game. I outright refuse.



dsister44 on 10 March 2010
trangentspree said:

I can only come up with one solution to this horrible dilema, but it requires the town believing that Falcon is the sole remaining mafia and that the SK is either myself or j0.

If the town double lynches j0 and falcon tonight and they are the SK and last mafia, the town wins.

If the town double lynches j0 and falcon tonight and falcon is the last mafia but j0 is really the nurse, the SK gets one last nightkill and there is a Day 7 with 3 players left. On Day 7 if jo is revealed to be the nurse I must be the SK and the town will lynch me, and the town wins.

As I said, this requires the town believing that there is only one remaining mafia.

 

No! There are two mafia left. There is no reason to think that one mafia is more powerful then the other. And you are guilty of everyhting you accused WoW of. Give me one reason why I should believe your claim.

 

This is how I see it.

Mafia 

  • Trangentspree
  • Falcon095

Serial Killer

  • Zexen_Lowe

You haven't even said that j0 isn't the nurse. You are just trying to change the conversation!



c03n3nj0 on 10 March 2010
trangentspree said:

I can only come up with one solution to this horrible dilema, but it requires the town believing that Falcon is the sole remaining mafia and that the SK is either myself or j0.

If the town double lynches j0 and falcon tonight and they are the SK and last mafia, the town wins.

If the town double lynches j0 and falcon tonight and falcon is the last mafia but j0 is really the nurse, the SK gets one last nightkill and there is a Day 7 with 3 players left. On Day 7 if jo is revealed to be the nurse I must be the SK and the town will lynch me, and the town wins.

As I said, this requires the town believing that there is only one remaining mafia.

 


This seems interesting, but easily, since I believe you to be most likely mafia, that would clear you for winning the whole game.

They kill the nurse today along with one of the mafia.

There's the SK and the remaining mafia left with 3 innocents. One of you each kill someone and the leaves a mafia, SK and townie left on the final day. Depending on how the lynch goes the town loses eiter way.

So yeah, we won't believe that there's only one mafia left.



 Tag (Courtesy of Fkusumot) "If I'm posting in this thread then it's probally a spam thread."                               

Around the Network
trangentspree on 10 March 2010
dsister44 said:
trangentspree said:

I can only come up with one solution to this horrible dilema, but it requires the town believing that Falcon is the sole remaining mafia and that the SK is either myself or j0.

If the town double lynches j0 and falcon tonight and they are the SK and last mafia, the town wins.

If the town double lynches j0 and falcon tonight and falcon is the last mafia but j0 is really the nurse, the SK gets one last nightkill and there is a Day 7 with 3 players left. On Day 7 if jo is revealed to be the nurse I must be the SK and the town will lynch me, and the town wins.

As I said, this requires the town believing that there is only one remaining mafia.

 

No! There are two mafia left. There is no reason to think that one mafia is more powerful then the other. And you are guilty of everyhting you accused WoW of. Give me one reason why I should believe your claim.

 

This is how I see it.

Mafia 

  • Trangentspree
  • Falcon095

Serial Killer

  • Zexen_Lowe

You haven't even said that j0 isn't the nurse. You are just trying to change the conversation!

I haven't said that j0 isn't the nurse? What are you talking about?!

I am the nurse, i refuse to believe that there are two nurses - ergo: jo isn't the nurse



trangentspree on 10 March 2010

And there is a case to be made for there only being one mafia left.

For one, Axum had a big ability - he was the mafiacop.

And also, as TheRepublic pointed out very early in the game, there is the law of 1/3.

Two lots of 4 mafia aside AND a serial killer makes 9 scum in this game! There were 26 players in this game to start out with.

26 - 9 = 14

9 vs 14 - does that look right to you? Consider how the town has benefited from a stupid amount of mafia modkills this game, and tell me this town would have had even a chance of winning with those numbers.



c03n3nj0 on 10 March 2010
trangentspree said:
c03n3nj0 said:
trangentspree said:
c03n3nj0 said:
trangentspree said:
c03n3nj0 said:
trangentspree said:
c03n3nj0 said:

I will Vote- Tangentspree

Why? I know for a fact that he's lying. And I want to double lynch Falcon095, with him. 

This put me in a disadvantage, though, 'cause tangent came up with awesome reasons all of a sudden. 

 

Why are you saying that you know for a fact I'm lying? Are trying to claim that you are the nurse???

Yep. 

I would've believed for a second that Truck may have put two nurses in, but the way you roleclaimed is way too scummy. 

And besides, a protective role would try to stay low as long as possible, you just went up and roleclaimed nurse as an excuse for lynching WoW. 

 

@ How could you believe for a second that Truck would put two nurses in the same game? That would be monstrously out of balance.

@ I had been following WoW carefully the whole game ever since he started demanding Doctor protection and then claiming he got it on the first night.

@ Well, thank you for proving my point. You're lying. >:D

@ That is why I said I may have believed it, it made some sense. But, how could you have known if she got it or not? And besides, we told you it wasn't out of the norm. And the final roleclaim seems like a final attempt to save your butt from suspicion. 

There is no way there could be two nurses in this game. No. Way. And I never said that I did know. I only said I didn't like that he was claiming that he did. This is a bullish lie on your part because after finding out Falcon is mafia and with my roleclaim, you knew you had no where to hide.

We didn't find out that WoW did get protection from the doctor on the first night until we found out that Arkzero was the doctor.


I should've worded that better, I wasn't accusing you of thinking that, it was a rhetorical question... or something along those lines.

Anyways, tell me, why did you choose to roleclaim nurse int he first place? You felt threatened? What I can't wrap my head around was that it doesn't make sense, besides trying to clear your name fromt he Wow mislynch.

This could be the final day j0.

We still have a serial killer at large and I can't tell if Falcon is the last mafia or not, at this stage it's useful to know who people actually are. And my roleclaiming is a no-lose scenario now, I can still protect disister one more night if I get targetted. If we get one more day that is. That means dsister will go through to the next day and will be able to carry out an investigation if needs be.

I don't understand why you seem to be backing down now. I refuse to believe there could be two nurses in this game. I outright refuse.


I wasn't backing down at all. >:[

I asked you to see what you're excuse was.

And I'm not buying it. People won't just assume today is the last day and roleclaim. There's still a possibility of two mafia running around, plus a serial killer. So it's common sense to still lay low, until you know for a fact that it's gonna be the last day.

And besides, it won't be any good of a nurse roleclaiming, do you honestly think a bad guy would still target dsister? They're still gonna be two kills during the night. You're points don't make sense at all. Thus, making you scum.



 Tag (Courtesy of Fkusumot) "If I'm posting in this thread then it's probally a spam thread."                               

dsister44 on 10 March 2010
trangentspree said:

I haven't said that j0 isn't the nurse? What are you talking about?!

I am the nurse, i refuse to believe that there are two nurses - ergo: jo isn't the nurse

You know what. After the way this game has turned out, and the way you have been playing it. I don't believe a word you are saying. Give me one reason why I should trust you above j0!

 



trangentspree on 10 March 2010
c03n3nj0 said:


I wasn't backing down at all. >:[

I asked you to see what you're excuse was.

And I'm not buying it. People won't just assume today is the last day and roleclaim. There's still a possibility of two mafia running around, plus a serial killer. So it's common sense to still lay low, until you know for a fact that it's gonna be the last day.

And besides, it won't be any good of a nurse roleclaiming, do you honestly think a bad guy would still target dsister? They're still gonna be two kills during the night. You're points don't make sense at all. Thus, making you scum.

@ Where do you think the mafia nightkill today disappeared to j0? I'm just dying to know the reason why you think someone with the ability to find out who mafia are is still no longer a threat to the mafia and worth killing.

There's a possibility of one or two mafia running around today, but it is you who seems desperate to assume there has to be two.

You have no points to make at all. You haven't even said why people should believe you are the nurse. You're just trying to confuse everyone into disbelieving me because there is a good chance of that happening based on today's results. You are scum.