I've read all the Berserk manga and played GOW 1 and 2...

I'd say Kratos would definitely win.

He would kill the five dudes of the god hand, the apostles and that huge demon from the latest chapters (you know, the "indian-like tyran" that looks like some giant tree/octopus), all at the same time, and right after that he would bang a few chicks (what Guts would definitely not do)

He raped Caska and had sex with the woman from the God hand

Wrong, SSJ4 Broly, the universe would instantly come to an end.

That was Hot

Gawd I miss the old Caska, she was like the black version of Lightning.

i have played beserker on the dc, but haven't read the manga. However, from what i gather, Guts is more psychotic next to Kratos.

as for coming back and fighting on from near death, say hello to Dante which always makes a come back from near death, Goku which actually comes back from death a lot, Ichigo who can be stabbed and have his soul taken over yet still manages to fight back.

Kratos wins it for me because he doesn't try, he actually does kill many gods, he goes through hell and back (lets face it, what can possibly be worse than hell?) and then he opens a can of woop ass on everything, yet remains in control of himself.

Since Guts cannot control himself, that automatically is a fail in a sense.

The fact that a mortal man can even be compared to the god of war shows how bad ass Guts is.

Nope. Kratos can do all that shit for the greeks, but when you start fucking with ppl that can bend space/time to there will ur talking multiverse bending kinds of shit then I don't give a fuck how many tricks Kratos can pull out of his ass. Take all that shit away from them both and suddenly you got 7 foot tall guts vs 5'8'' Kratos Guts wins. Give them swords make it easy for Kratos give him two swords fuck the chains Guts wins. Give Kratos range Guts wins MOFO got a cannon. Give Kratos his bow or w/e it is in GOW3 guts wins sword big enough to shield himself from a cannon blast arrows aren't doing shit.

Kratos two swords vs Guts Zweihander one normal hand one iron= Guts wins he'd smash the blades and were talking Kratos no chains just swords

Kratos chain blades/range vs Guts Dragonslayer+cannon= Guts wins tbh most of the gameplay in GOW goes on the basis that his blades can make concrete into butter change that fact to him being unable to cut through the dragonslayer and you got a lockup on his dumbass chains cannon blast to the body and he's dead. Also every opening technique requires Kratos to snap his arms open in a bird like motion which leaves him completely open thrust or cannon blast to the sternum or both stab to the chest immobilization cannon to the face. Guts wins

Kratos vs. Guts in a fistfight= Guts wins with one arm and his elbow no iron (it's called reach)

Giant Kratos vs Berserker Armor Guts with his mind intact= Epic Guts win. Giant Kratos would be handicapped looking for Guts an he'd prolly bore into Kratos' guts and turn his innards to swiss cheese

Kratos trying some underhanded fate string chopping bs Guts wins. he doesn't have a fate string he died as a child an he has no destiny hence Guts' uber fucked up life

In all of my scenarios Guts wins but it doesn't mean Kratos is a pansy it just means that the fight would end with Guts being the victor the issue is Kratos style as flashy as spinning around is in a video game. If you put him up against physics from Guts universe where his little chain dance doesn't work he'd have some fucking issues which would make Guts the ultimate victor. Also seeing how ppl started jumping into who's character was more fucked up I'd have to say Kratos is dumb for being a loner Guts has powerful allies so he wouldn't be alone in the fight meanwhile Kratos pissy attitude would pit him in a fight with a summoner and an assassin with a blade that emits wind that turns ppl into swiss cheese +Guts but in a 1v1 it's still stacked in Guts favor. Now if i'm neglecting Kratos' more stabbing prone combos then he'd have to get into reach of guts body which has a 6 foot sword that moves just as fast if not faster than Kratos' moves, but what about the chains wouldn't that wrap around guts and make him into swiss cheese... nope Guts has dexterity as well as strength he'd pin the sword into the ground lift himself above his sword arch his body towards Kratos.. vertical swipe split Kratos in half done an done. Wouldn't Kratos whip his blades back...? Figuring Guts just jammed the blade feet in front of him the chain would wrap around the dragonslayer which would get tangled around the blade so Kratos would prolly end up eating some of his own chain.

What if Kratos gets lucky and gets guts down... Obviously Kratos would have to finish it which Guts is famous for playing possum and then cannon shot Mad hack an slash Kratos dead Guts dying but....+ puck/ allies Guts wins.... It's Kratos' loner attitude that puts him in the shithouse. 

Don't Believe Guts has Dexterity http://view.thespectrum.net/series/berserk-volume-01.html?ch=Volume+18&page=27 proof. 

Oh an to whoever says to cut his Guts Fate string in the tapestry he doesn't have one he was dead from the beginning if you recollect from the beginning he was already dead and has been chased by death for his entire life. Hence the Skull Knight's nickname for Guts, the struggler. He doesn't accept anything he fights against fate. Now if you put Guts against the shit Kratos fought against I'd see Guts knocking out Ares without the magic mushroom. Shit he'd figure it out.

Kratos isnt the god of war...

Whatever Guts does, Kratos repels with his golden fleece....Kratos wins without even trying...he'll probably rip Guts' guts out....

guts by far.