Im voting ME2. I own the first (and have beaten it) and I will definitely buy the second (on PC). I still think its completely overrated. I enjoyed the game, but in no way shape or form do I absolutely love it. I think its over hyped, but that does not mean it is not worth my time.

All those games have inflated expectations but that doesn't make them over-rated. Expectation vs result doesn't mean a game is over-rated or under-rated. Under-rated means that the game got less praise after release than it deserves and vice-versa. Since something like GOW is more niche I would expect more people who hate the game to consider it over-rated than Halo: Reach.

Edit: In addition to this, considering that GOW 3 will probably rank with the highest graphics scores and given the numerous gameplay vs graphics arguments coming strongly in favour of gameplay >>>>> graphics in terms of number of proponents, these same people may consider it to be over-rated based on that metric alone if considering review scores.

Because thse games to me have the most hype and have more of a chance to be overrated.

....Zelda Wii doesn't even have a title yet. And it's not the only one on your list

SO?

It's hard to hype vaporware

I picked FF13 but I should have said Reach. I know Halo is Halo so it'll be a good game, but it looks like just a spinoff and not a sequel/prequel (or whatever it is)

I voted for COD7 but there still games there that I have a feeling will be another overhype shit e.g FF13 and reach.

Either God of War III or Halo Reach (imo).

I wanted to pick Alan Wake but it is not there :s How could you leave out one of the biggest 360 exclusives? lol

I say Alan Wake since it looks a tad bit boring. I was interested in this game until I seen the gameplay video of the guy walking around some kind of ranch flashing his torch on some supernatural beings. I think the story will be far better than the gameplay, then again I might be wrong, but then again from what I have seen, it doesn't rock my boat :S