I don't know because I haven't played DS yet.

But I just have that feeling that I'd prefer DS over Uncharted 2, just a feeling...

patapon said: Uncharted 2 and Demon's Souls are probably 2009's most monumental games. Both are great choices! (if you got the DS pun, you get a cookie )

but there is only ONE monumental left and only one should get the award!

Pun pun pun!

they are both on the best third place console ever created.

It's just tough when you have to decide between so many great games.

Demon's Souls winning is fantastic. I look at it like this: We all KNEW Uncharted 2 would be awesome, so a good deal of our passion for the game is gone because it lived up (and exceeded) our expectations.

I expected I would enjoy Demon's Souls when I first heard about it, but I would have never believed a game like this would make me WANT to talk about at all times and all situations. I get so excited just talking about the game than I do any other game released so far on the ps3.

This makes it an easy GOTY for me.

U2 was the superior game in every single way. It deserved all the 10/10's it recieved.

With that being said however, DS is a fantastic game with great fun that I'd recommend to anyone who is looking for a good dungeon crawling or stat padding or weapon combat fighting ect ect game. I'd just reccomend U2 to every single person though...

After playing both... I prefer Demon's Souls no contest.

Something tells me Uncharted 2 will win overall GOTY tomorrow tho...

No it did not, the only game that I think should have given Uncharted 2 a run for its money was Killzone 2

Played both (got the Plat for U2 also) Demon's Souls is the superior game imo.

Uncharted was great, it probably would've been my GOTY if it weren't for DS but Demon's Souls is just like one of those games that you will remember no matter how many years or consoles pass.