Same here, I thought sure they were going to give it to MW2. I was glad Uncharted 2 got it even though I don't have a PS3 and have never played the game. Everything I have read about it makes it seem worthy.

Umm, if you had seen what Seece had written above me before he edited it, this whould have made more sense.

The trailer in HD

Have to say the graphics are excellent. Really can't wait to see gameplay. Maybe remake Halo 1 with this engine

WTH happened here? lots got banned cause they wernt impressed?

Bit of an over-exagerration. Only two was banned.
One for an obvious trolling which even you must see and the other for saying it sucked and nothing more.
Not being impressed is one thing and sugar coating their comments but "it sucked" is neither helpful or informative and doesn't expand on why he didn't like it.
That said his ban does seem a bit extreme. I don't get that but there must be more to it.
Raifs on the other hand was completely justified.

A couple of things from the trailer caught my attention. It sounds like halo reach will have 6 player co-op and each character will have a skill set, Sniper, Assault...ect. Did anyone else catch anything that could reveal the type of gameplay this game will have.

Edit:  Actually after thinking about it a little more it probably means you'll have six different spartans with different skill sets to choose from in the Single Player...and the MP as well.

I just watchet it and was blown away!  It's gonna be the best halo ever, and easily GOTY 2010, and there will most likely never be a game that ever surpasses it MP wise

Don't underestimate the competition, have you seen the games coming out in 2010.

Mario Galaxy 2

Final Fantasy XIII (Which we already know is being well-recieved among critics)

Last Guardian

Zelda Wii ( It may actually come out 2011)

God of War 3

Heavy Rain

Gran Turismo

Mass Effect 2

Alan Wake

That is stiff competition, I believe it won't make it due to the sheer competition and overall quality these titles may bring.

uh, dood, Halo fans are kinda like Star Trek people or Star Wars people at this point, why are you even trying? o_O;

So for that reason, by default it deserves GOTY. That's just a retarded assumption.