One other thing, if Zexen is in fact a mafia trying to mislynch WoW. Wouldn't the real Cop come in and clear everything up? You know, since WoW is too important to lose like this....

It really sucks to be vanilla.

I'd love to claim that I'm the Cop or Doctor, but I can't.  zexen couldn't have predicted that and that's why he had to be the one to do this.  If I had had been the Cop then it would have been a better contest of who believes who.  However, the best I can do as vanilla townsfolk is repeat over and over that zexen is mafia and hope that someone will believe me before I end up getting mislynched.

And no, I don't mean I've never lost a game I survived.  I mean literally that I've never lost a game as Pro-Town.  In one of them I was double-lynched at the end (after finding mafia no less >.>), but luckily the town still won.

Not all of the town has gotten here since his post so who knows..

@j0: The real cop wouldn't come forward because that would make him extremely vulnerable to night kills since the doctor wouldn't know whether to protect zexen or the real cop.

With this many players, we could have multiple Cops/Doctors so having a real Cop roleclaim would only help if he also investigated me and could testify that I'm innocent.  (edit:  or got a guilty on zexen)

And even then, if we lynch zexen after a real Cop proves my innocence then it means that it's likely I or the real Cop would be without protection during the night so the mafia gets the chance to kill one of us anyway.

Wrong, there's still a 50/50 chance of protection which is generally considered enough to scare off mafia.  In fact, I believe we've talked about this and used this very strategy to milk multiple protections out of a doctor before.  Were you a bad guy in that game?  Did something change your mind about the viability of that tactic?  Or are you lying scum?  

This is like the OP.  I swear I'm the only one who reads those end-of-game actions.  In almost every one of those games the Doctor protected the Cop instead of me.

And no, I'm not lying nor scum.  I'm vanilla townsfolk.  Zexen is mafia.  And you're helping him mislynch me.

Vote: Words Of Wisdom

Damn we're in a difficult situation here.. In one hand we have a cop claiming to have found a mafia, on the other, we have the accused saying its a lie..

We have 3 options
1- We follow the cop and lynch WoW
2- We lynch zexen to see if he's a cop
3- We don't lynch either to see which one is right next day.

From those 2 seems like the worst because in case zex is telling the truth we would loose a cop and let WoW go away with it..

To be honest.. I'm not brave enough to lynch WoW in this situation, and while I have the feeling she's guilty for how she has acted so far, like I said, I'm not brave enough to take the risk. I vote for option 3, if you guys want to lynch her, so be it.