http://www.1up.com/do/reviewPage?cId=3176906

WOOT! A+ Baby! Outstanding review!

that is surprising, they are always very harsh on wii games...but i´ts mario and the game seems to be tons of fun.

Pretty good!

Hah, awesome. Don't wanna spoil too much for myself, so I only watched a bit of the vid there, but I'm having so much fun just watching them play...

I liked one of the questions asked ~3:50 - "warlock82 says, uh... he wants to know if Nintendo made any attempt at all to give the two toads any sort of story. Or background."
*room bursts out in laughter*

Anyway, I'm liking the reviews... It seems 2D Mario is tough to hate on, even for "hardcore." Nostalgia wins!

Wow finally a good review from such a biased source. I'm really happy to see even 1.Up can find barely anything wrong with it. Sure they snuck in the part about not being able to play as Peach making a second generic toad playable instead. But knowing that 1.Up a totally biased website couldn't find a way to trash NSMBW I am even more excited then before. Can't wait to pick my copy up sunday!

They are doing it wrong. Not many people will pay attention unless you review like IGN/Gamespot, LOL. those threads are way longer.

Could have got the game 3 days ago but will wait till saturday and get it at nintendo world event!