its up there with sonic 2+3 as my favourite games ever

no it's not my new number 1, not by a long shot. Definitely in the group of 'best games this generation' though.

Doesn't have a chance at cracking into my top 10 games of all time...

yah uncharted 2 is one of my favorites, on my ps3 i really liked killzone2, infamous, res 1 and 2, drakes fortune, the first one, and a hugh god of war fan, god of war 3 is the only game i could see competing with u2, other games im looking forward to, MAG, bad company2, alan wake, killzone3, res3, halo reach, i was disappointed with odst, oh and splinter cell conviction

My only major complaint I have with UC2 is that I never felt like I was going to die on all these death defying leaps. You kinda just come to expect a pipe breaking when you grab on to it or a rock coming loose and you move on.

I do love the game. The production values are top notch and the story is great. If you have the means to play this game, you need to do it.  But it's not my favorite game all time.  Not sure if its even in my top 10.

naa, I still have Super Metroid, Final Fantasy Tactics and Warcraft 3 too close to my heart, but from this generation, I would say yes, ... so far.

I agree with you STAGE. I wasn't crazy about the gameplay in U1, though I fell in love with the story and characters. I think they improved the gameplay and enemies in almost every way in U2. I loved it.

Btw, explain what you mean by linear?

Awesome campaign but, I'm already trying to sell Uncharted 2....the replay value just isn't keeping me hooked.