everybody has an opinion, remember microsoft had to get sued before facing there responsability with rrod, many lawsuits, but i have had both systems for about 2 years, im on my original ps3 , iv had every update they have offered with no problems, no with my 360 im on my 7th concole with them, everything from rrod, to video card or motherboard failing, to dvd drive failing, so everybody has different experiences, now my cousin had a problem with his ps3 out of warranty and the fixed it for free, no prob, so try not to be to hard on any of them , no large company is perfect and everybody has different experiences with them. if i have affended anyone with this , sorry