ah Rare, I miss you : (

I think in his own weird way he is being sarcastic.

I believe Rare will  be successful in creating a FPS using Natal as well GH . But as one reviewer on Natal already admitted while Natal works he still rather use a controller.
The way I see it , the hard part is not finding uses for Natal but to have gamers wanting to putting down their controllers.

 I take  force feedback sheering wheel any day over the plain wheels of yesteryear or a controller  so I know I don't want to race without a wheel with Natal.

PullusPardus said: and Still i'd like to see it in action. GH with guitar fails GH without Guitar fails even more , but i like seeing something more fun. this is thread number 41564 of "wow natal is awesome... you have our words on it" , i don't trust words

Who said anything about not having a guitar with GH?  Natal could and should be used along with the guitar. 

Natal could place your avatar on stage and detect what your doing if your standing up, not to mention you wouldn't need another mic.  There are tons of things possible other than just an AIR Guitar.  

I'm curious why so many people automatically jumped to the conclusion of "Guitar Hero without a guitar" and then labeled it a "fail". Maybe they were alluding to dynamic animations of the characters on stage while a group of people are playing? Or maybe a peripheral without buttons specifically meant for Natal's mapping abilities which might reduce the price of the peripheral/game?

There are quite a few possibilities.

damndl0ser said: PullusPardus said: and Still i'd like to see it in action. GH with guitar fails GH without Guitar fails even more , but i like seeing something more fun. this is thread number 41564 of "wow natal is awesome... you have our words on it" , i don't trust words Who said anything about not having a guitar with GH?  Natal could and should be used along with the guitar.  Natal could place your avatar on stage and detect what your doing if your standing up, not to mention you wouldn't need another mic.  There are tons of things possible other than just an AIR Guitar.

Beat me to it. That's the last time I hold off hitting the Post button to finish some work

I don't know, I just didn't think there's much to do with Natal and Guitar Hero. But then again, capturing your body movement while playing the guitar along with a recording option would be pretty cool.

PS3 holding back the 360 confirmed.

I think Natal will be good. I also think that most of the people already owning a 360 will buy the Natal without looking back expensive or not. But will it push hardware sales? If not expensive i think yes

Natal just as a add on seems too familiar with what has been done with PSeye as of now. Only a few games support it  but that's about it. Even using head tracking with the PSeye with GT5 seems useful but still I doubt very many gamers will go out and buy the PSeye just for that purpose. Now the wand may finally help PSeye be more supported than just a gimmick.