By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Gaming - IGN's review of Magnacarta 2 is an utter joke

inverted3reality said:
magna carta 2 is a pretty bad game. I dont see how this review is flawed.

Please describe to me how this game is bad?  And please dont use the teleprompter that is another individuals review, this should be based on your sole playing of this game.



Around the Network

There are also a good number of people who are convinced that Lost Odyssey stands up there with the greatest JRPGs of all time.

So I don't listen to what most JRPG fans say this gen. Reviewers are far more in touch with RPG quality than most of the people who play them.



 

 

This just in! Opinions are not fact! More at 11.



forest-spirit said:
Damn, you are angry...What if the game actually isn't that good? No...impossible...

And what, from now on IGN can't give a better score to any JRPG than what they gave Magna Carta II? So Magna Carta II is the best JRPG of all time then, huh?

Every JRPG ain't good, deal with it...

Why would I be angry?  Im just calling out a reviewer on his call of a game.

The qualities that IGN gives other RPG higher scores for it nixes Magna Carta II, im questioning the double standards.   They should have had, if possible, the original reviewer of the originial magna carta review this one to show what has improved and what went in decline.  The review, if bad, would have been more believeable.

And no every JRPG is not good, thats why I spend my money and time playing them to fact check these individuals to prevent them from spewing random garbabe about games like this.



Barozi said:
A Bad Clown said:
He didn't like it! Why do you care? If you like playing mediocre games to spend your time go buy it.

Metacritic disagrees with you

Not for long, it only has 8 reviews as of now. When more reviews comes in it will fall under 70 pretty fast. I expet this to be slaughtered by edge, gt, gamespot ect.