Look I'm all for people rating games how they see fit but in 1 thread they give a game 10/10 that has a short campaign and no replay value and another thread they give a 7.5 and state the downsides are a short campaign and no replay value. You have to question that. Also if you read a lot of his posts you can sense the PS3 hate.

I'm not even going to go into your score. Repetitive lol. Assasins creed that was repetitive. Uncharted is far from repetitive.

The J-man's favorite game this gen is Bioshock. And he said in this thread that if thee campaign is long enough then it makes up for it, and Bioshock took me longer to beat than Uncharted. As well as the fact that I believe that Bioshock has two different endings depending on if you save the little sisters or absorb them

And yes Assassin's Creed was repetitive. But every shooter is repetitive especially third person

Bioshock (although little) had somewhat of a morality system where whether or not you harvest the little sisters or not gives you a different ending and how the little sister treat you when you enter their safehouse.

Thats at least something to bring you back into the game.

Desmond , I see very little reason for me to justify my score whether or not I give it a 10/10 , 7.5/10 or 3/10 is none of your concern.

Go back to rating 360 games lower because of the fact that its on the 360 and stop replying to me.

look I don't really care about this anymore.

You shouldnt have to begin with...

Oh and I have platted bioshock I know exactly whats in the game. apart from a different ending, the little sisters giving you presents and more adam and them calling you a bad man or there savior there isn't much differance the second time you play it.

And by the way I don't rate 360 games, even the ones I've played because I preferr the PS3 more and I would only rate the games low and yes I have played a lot of 360 games.

I'll give this game a 9.0.

The gameplay was very fun, I enjoyed the story, graphics were great, but some of the shooting got annoying and it was a little short.

Says a lot about you then doesn't it.

8/10, good game but vastly overrated by the fans on this site (which probably contributed to my disappointment).

Pros: Great graphics
Fun fights
Cons: Repetitive
Too short

@Yo_john

Any chance of LBP coming anytime soon? I think that game could easily knock MGS4 off the top