8.5
Game was very good, story-wise, it was astonishing, but the things that kept this game from being a 9.5 are the repetitive enemies, the city was a bit too uniform and the side mission were also repetitive. If these flaws were fixed for a second game, 9.5 hands down.

Bah I don't agree with the 100 post thing because I don't have a ton of time for the net, BUT i understand to keep away from having the "alt attack to lower score" fanboy thing. Anyway...

9.1

Good
-Excellent game, loved the sandbox freedom.
-Good and Bad story lines made replay factor high (also going through for all the dang shards does)
-Powers were sheer fun (more variety next time, although good job for the first installment)
-Graphics were incredible (the "infamous" glitches (LOL) were not that bad IMO)

Bad
-Tad repetitive at times (next version they need to change the enemies up more)
-Bystanders need to get the HECK out of the way, they drive me batty while playing as good lol

7.5

No glaring flaws, but at the same time, totally forgetable. Main character is cliché and lacks charisma. Graphics are average. Side missions a repetitive.

The powers are great, though.

8.8/10

+ Powers
+ Karma choices
+ The uber twist in the story
+ Final battle is sick

- Some glitches
- Counter surveillance missions
- Not enough boss fights

9.2

+Great platforming
+Super fun gameplay
+Very good city design
+Awesome abilities
+Combat system is very fun
+Choice between being the hero or villain
+Beautiful cutscenes

-Not really open world
-Pretty easy, even on hard
-No super tall skyscrapers to scale

8.3

10 hours left to vote!

@yo_john117

am really loving this

keep up the good work

9.1

+ Story
+ Story - again. Since its different Good/Bad
+ Gameplay
+ Karma system
+ Side missions
+ Artwork
+ RPG elements
+ Trophies
+ Vertical gameplay
+ Funfactor

- Glitches
- Boss fights
- Variation of enemies
- Replay value - after 8 playthroughs both good and bad, i can't see why i should pick it up again within the near future.
- No DLC

8.9

Which funnily enough matches my review of the title:

http://vgchartz.com/games/gamereviewdisp.php?id=13108&reviewid=331