Actually I played OoT for the first time last year. And I thought it was crap. So to me Uncharted was better than OoT. It's all just an opinion. If people think this will be better than OoT who are are you to say their opinion is idiotic?

Of course he is entitled to say he believes it will be heralded as the greatest game of this generation or any gen, but any person is entitled to make this claim of any game.

Ocarina's claim to fame is that it is almost universaly held in exceptionally high esteem not only among games of it's generation but across generations and continues to do so long after it's release.  It's just far, far too early to make any such claims about U2.

I never said he wasn't allowed to believe it. Just like I said why aren't people allowed to believe Uncharted is just like OoT to them. 

I was talking about the way he phrased it. Why is it an "idiotic comparison" if people think this? Everyone is entitled to an opinion. Just because someone has a different one doesn't make them an idiot.

EDIT: Think I misunderstood what you meant but ah well.

No, OoT is considered great because it added a ton of things that changed how pepole looked at gaming.
It didn't age that well.

Well that at least bumps it up to a rental for me. I didn't care much for the first one, but this one looks like it improves it at least a good bit. I played the multiplayer demo and thought it was boring, and the single player in the last one I just wasn't that into. It was very good, highly polished, ect, I just didn't find it particularly interesting and I don't really have any good memories of playing the game. I don't want to shell out 60 bucks for another experience like that. I'll wait for Demon Souls and MW2.

And no, this isn't this generation OOT. The hype and interest is just a fraction of what OOT was in the day, there is no Time Magazine article about uncharted 2, there is less than 300,000k pre-orders and it is 4th on the pre-order chart. Uncharted isn't going to make large changes to game design that will be felt for generations. Such a statement is just hyperbole and you could insert killzone 2, Uncharted 1, Halo 3, Gears Of War 2, Modern Warfare 2, Final Fantasy XIII or any other big game into that slot and it would have the same merit. Which is to say "It's hyped up, and has alot of work put into it, so it's like this generations OOT!!"

very good review on gametrailers!!!!!

I think: Metal Gear Solid 4 > Yakuza 3 > Uncharted 2 > Gears of War 2 > All other games ^^

Well GT made a 360 game look ugly then compared it the the 360 one and said that the crappy one was for ps3 right ?

great review for a great looking game :)

Atleast it didn't get below a 9.0

What the fuck, are people actually complaining that a game they haven't played through yet ONLY got a 9.3??? And some are claiming GT bias because of this? SERIOUSLY? Jeese, why do reviewers even bother. Players grade the games before they even come out and they know the real score, not the lame ass biased score, so why bother trying to fool them with you're 9.3s?