Wii: Not really
DS: Yes

I'd agree with this if it weren't for the impending domination of Spirit Tracks in the handheld sphere.

A very lackluster line up says no.

if Uncharted 2 and MW2 werent this year Id say yes

DS: without a doubt on the handheld side.
Wii: not really. This has been a pretty slow year for the wii in terms of huge 10/10 titles. NSMB might have a chance, but I think Uncharted 2 is currently setting the stakes pretty high in terms of ratings this year.

Nope. Critics have hated the Wii since day one. Expect it to be a PS3/360 game all the way.

for me, yes. Which is all that counts, right?

*Pelted by crumbled paper balls*

On GameRankings, GTA: Chinatown Wars and Mario & Luigi are both make the top 10 rated games of the year. So there's no reason why these shouldn't get nominated and perhaps even win a few awards.

As for NSMB Wii, we'll have to wait and see. I don't expect critics to go nuts over that game.

If SMBW has the same level design as mario world it'll win with no problem

Don't forget Punch out, that games great