By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Sony - Games Radar give uncharted 2 a 10/10

Maybe MS was afraid to let the ODST reviews go ?

I don't know if they're fake, but I saw a 40/100 and a 64/100 review for ODST...



Around the Network
fifa10 said:
Wow ! Surprising, considering gamesradar is among the worst MS fanboy websites, along with Eurogamer and Edge...

I guess it must be really good.


Hey, I'm a huge Xbox supporter, I don't even own a PS3 and I think everything about this game looks like an amazing experience. You gotta be willing to call a spade a spade, and a diamond a diamond, or you are not a real gamer. If ODST is a stinker, you bet your ass I'll be here making a thread calling Bungie out!



nordlead said:

^^^

Maybe they are reviewing a build based off the betas?? Either way, I doubt the game deserves a 10/10, but to each their own.

Honestly, I scanned over the review and it sounds like a PS3 fanboy review. For example, "PS3 officially has its a killer-app and a million tears are shed by 360 fanboys. "

EDIT: thats what happens when you decide to actually follow the link. You don't get done reading in time for your original post to be pointing at the right person


I see what you mean...lol. the other review on PSN magazine is even funnier. Its quote on metacritic is...

"A veritable master class of all-round game development. From a sensational single-player experience that never takes any short-cuts and maintains its story's mythological credibility right to the end to the co-operative online play to the robust, balanced, and just plain fun multiplayer modes, this is a package of content that more than earns its $60 price tag... [It's] this season's biggest PS3 victory."

Its hard to take a review seriously when its polishing a games knob like that...



i really appreciate the early reviews for sony games. it allows for more educated purchases.



art is the excrement of culture

fifa10 said:
Maybe MS was afraid to let the ODST reviews go ?

I don't know if they're fake, but I saw a 40/100 and a 64/100 review for ODST...

Oh noes, Too human part 2?

Seriously though, I'll let you know if it sucks after tonight...



Around the Network
fifa10 said:
Maybe MS was afraid to let the ODST reviews go ?

I don't know if they're fake, but I saw a 40/100 and a 64/100 review for ODST...

There is an embargo you know ..



 

fifa10 said:
Maybe MS was afraid to let the ODST reviews go ?

I don't know if they're fake, but I saw a 40/100 and a 64/100 review for ODST...

I believe the 4/10 was from a Wii Fanboy website. I'm not sure where the 64/100 came from, but that is probably fake too. Even if it is just Halo 3 + Expansion it wouldn't deserve such a low score because it has all the Halo 3 multiplayer content which people love.




If you drop a PS3 right on top of a Wii, it would definitely defeat it. Not so sure about the Xbox360. - mancandy
In the past we played games. In the future we watch games. - Forest-Spirit
11/03/09 Desposit: Mod Bribery (RolStoppable)  vg$ 500.00
06/03/09 Purchase: Moderator Privilege  vg$ -50,000.00

Nordlead Jr. Photo/Video Gallery!!! (Video Added 4/19/10)

Gaming magazines often have their review of a new game at the same time that a game releases (often times, before!). They get copies before retailers do. I think the review is legit, and I will be pre-ordering.



libellule said:
disolitude said:
Games not out for a month. how do sony games get these early reviews? Killzone 2 had reviews a month in advance.

Halo ODST is out in 5 ays and we are still waiting for a review...

 

- preview built can be sent to reviewer, it is not the finished game but it is close so some site use them to make their review

- there is an embargo on Halo ODST review

MS used their money (guess) to not allow people to release their review too early.
One would say it is because the game sucks, or it is not worth the money (too short) but I will not allow my self to say it (it is perhaps good after all ...)

also, u dont want review to break the insane amont of preorder in the USA alone ?

(I know, even if the review are bad, those guys will get the game anyway ...)

I work in online advertising and have worked for sites and online publishers before. There is no money changing hands for reviews... Publishers have to follow review embargo dates and this could be why the Halo review is not out.

However IGN is releasing it on Satuday...well before the game is out. So by Monday lots of reviews should be available.

Anywho, I just find it suspicios when game gets reviewed a month early. Kinda like ..."here, you can review this early if you hype it up and make it seem like its the best game ever"



disolitude said:
Games not out for a month. how do sony games get these early reviews? Killzone 2 had reviews a month in advance.

Halo ODST is out in 5 ays and we are still waiting for a review...

naughty Dog just decided to send games out early and not have an embargo.  Halo ODST was done months ago and they could've done the exact same thing, they just decided not to.



...