I have just tried visiting gamefaqs to look at people's reaction to the score. Nothing. Then I tried to go to the 360 board, only to find that gamefaqs main page for 360 is covered by ps3 advertisement. No such ad on gamefaqs main page for ps3. Lol.

Haze was hyped to be a "halo killer" and it received a 50 from US Playstation mag

Don't you see it by now? Atleast 75% of the Sony threads made, meaning about hardware or software, gets trashed by MOSTLY 360 fanboys. 

They are jealous.

as for the review

they gacve GTA:SA the same score & that was one of my best games of all time

some italian ninty mag gave SMG a 11/10.....thats one of my best games ever

IGN said they wanted to give MGs4 a 11/10.....thats one of my best games ever

I see a trend here.....hyped or not.....this does tell us one thing, uncharted 2 will definetely be in the 90's on the meta

& now is officially a BIG BIG contender for GOTY.

Quick translation for you: (I'm french canadian)

+ : Excellent realisation

Completely crazy gunfights

Amazing "life expectancy"

- : there's no way to avoid this game

"Long, beautiful, deep and explosive, Uncharted 2 contains all qualities we are looking for in a videogame, and even more ! It (the game) truly scored a new height in the history of video games, embodying the new standard of entertainment on console gaming".

------

+ : Une réalisation sublime
Des gunfights complétement dingues
Une durée de vie de ouf

- : pas Moyen de passer à côté

"Long, beau, profond et explosif, Uncharted 2 cumule toutes les qualités qu'on peut rechercher dans un jeu vidéo, et bien plus encore ! Il vient véritablement de marquer un nouveau tournant dans l'histoire vidéoludique, s'affirmant comme le nouveau standard du divertissement sur console".

Note : 21/20

I think a publication loses all credibility when they rate a game above 100%. All their doing is hyping the game to a level that can never be realisticaly reached by any game.

PSM Magazine is a respected mag here in France. They are not biased (by the past they've been very critical against killzone 2 and resistance 2 for example).This 21/20 is their way to express that they think that Uncharted 2 just set a new milestone in gaming.
According to them, The game is beautiful, longer, with an extraordinary carry out and the gunfights are crazy.

I don't think most people are being negative towards the game like some people are stating.... I think it's mostly that people that are jaded by reviewers.

THANK YOU very much,. I have added this to the OP & given credit to you for it

@sweep

THIS is very encouraging to hear

I confirm the translation

on a side note jeuxvideo.com is the most important videogames related website in France (it is also a bulshit one lol, too much fanboy)