By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Gaming - Wii 9 times more reliable than Xbox 360, 4 times more than PS3

Seinfeld said:
Demotruk said:
That's dealt with in the report, actually. Under the heading "Usage is a factor, but Wii is still more reliable".

Usage factor aside, its old technology. Notice how tiny it is? Put a screen on it and its portable.


Small size usually adds to the problem of overheating... That's why PC's are so large and have so much space for air to move around in them.  You're helping to make the point that it's really well made by pointing out it's small size and still being so reliable.



A game I'm developing with some friends:

www.xnagg.com/zombieasteroids/publish.htm

It is largely a technical exercise but feedback is appreciated.

Around the Network
Demotruk said:
Seinfeld said:
Demotruk said:
That's dealt with in the report, actually. Under the heading "Usage is a factor, but Wii is still more reliable".

Usage factor aside, its old technology. Notice how tiny it is? Put a screen on it and its portable.


Small size usually adds to the problem of overheating... That's why PC's are so large and have so much space for air to move around in them.  You're helping to make the point that it's really well made by pointing out it's small size and still being so reliable.


Is that why PCs are so large? I wonder how laptops are so small with the same processors? Hmmmm....

Also, perhaps a HD console GPU and Processor produce considerable more heat than the primitive technology of the Wii.



Even if you use more advanced technology the product should be reliable. Imo higher technology is no excuse for higher failure rates.



Soriku said:
Seinfeld said:
Demotruk said:
That's dealt with in the report, actually. Under the heading "Usage is a factor, but Wii is still more reliable".

Usage factor aside, its old technology. Notice how tiny it is? Put a screen on it and its portable.


Naturally, with better technology, there will be improvements. But apparently that's not the case with reliability seeing as how this "old technology" console is more reliable than the "next gen" ones.


Reliability has become a problem with everything. I can't find a quality desk anymore and cars dent from leaning on them.

Seinfeld said:
Demotruk said:
Seinfeld said:
Demotruk said:
That's dealt with in the report, actually. Under the heading "Usage is a factor, but Wii is still more reliable".

Usage factor aside, its old technology. Notice how tiny it is? Put a screen on it and its portable.


Small size usually adds to the problem of overheating... That's why PC's are so large and have so much space for air to move around in them.  You're helping to make the point that it's really well made by pointing out it's small size and still being so reliable.


Is that why PCs are so large? I wonder how laptops are so small with the same processors? Hmmmm....

Also, perhaps a HD console GPU and Processor produce considerable more heat than the primitive technology of the Wii.


Have you never noticed how hot laptops get?

 

And yes, they produce far more heat. That's the point. Wii's processor is very energy efficient compared to the HD's, but also so are the other parts inside the Wii. They also deliberately have less moving parts and thus make less noise.

 

We all know that the HD consoles are less reliable because their processors are more powerful (without the kind of cooling you'd get in a desktop PC), but that isn't much of an excuse. If people are fully aware of this and still choose to trade reliability for power, that's fair enough for them, but it's not much of an excuse for making an unreliable consumer product.



A game I'm developing with some friends:

www.xnagg.com/zombieasteroids/publish.htm

It is largely a technical exercise but feedback is appreciated.

Around the Network

LOL are people REALLY trying to spin this against the Wii because it's hardware is weaker? truly pathetic.

There has never been a generation where Nintendo hasn't had the most reliable product, it's only natural that it continues. If the graphical prowess of the 360 and PS3 caused higher failure rates, that's a terrible business decision and shows that electronics were not ready for the increase in power.

Too many stupid people in this thread, and the only cure for stupidity is death.



Demotruk said:
Seinfeld said:
Demotruk said:
Seinfeld said:
Demotruk said:
That's dealt with in the report, actually. Under the heading "Usage is a factor, but Wii is still more reliable".

Usage factor aside, its old technology. Notice how tiny it is? Put a screen on it and its portable.


Small size usually adds to the problem of overheating... That's why PC's are so large and have so much space for air to move around in them.  You're helping to make the point that it's really well made by pointing out it's small size and still being so reliable.


Is that why PCs are so large? I wonder how laptops are so small with the same processors? Hmmmm....

Also, perhaps a HD console GPU and Processor produce considerable more heat than the primitive technology of the Wii.


Have you never noticed how hot laptops get?

 

And yes, they produce far more heat. That's the point. Wii's processor is very energy efficient compared to the HD's, but also so are the other parts inside the Wii. They also deliberately have less moving parts and thus make less noise.

 

We all know that the HD consoles are less reliable because their processors are more powerful (without the kind of cooling you'd get in a desktop PC), but that isn't much of an excuse. If people are fully aware of this and still choose to trade reliability for power, that's fair enough for them, but it's not much of an excuse for making an unreliable consumer product.


At one point in time Wii technology required a machine as big as a PC. Remember the Xbox? The Wii is old technology that was dealt with years ago. The 360 is/was cutting edge technology and it had unprecedented problems.

My point is you can't compare the two. As far as technology goes they are from two different generations.



Seinfeld said:

At one point in time Wii technology required a machine as big as a PC. Remember the Xbox? The Wii is old technology that was dealt with years ago. The 360 is/was cutting edge technology and it had unprecedented problems.

My point is you can't compare the two. As far as technology goes they are from two different generations.

Old technology is innacurate. It's a less powerful processor, or the same power as earlier computers but smaller and more energy efficient. Nobody has denied that part of the reason the Wii can be so small and still be reliable and rarely overheat is because it doesn't have the kind of processing the HD consoles have. However what we are saying is that being powerful is not an excuse for poor reliability in a consumer product. Most people expect better than a 1 in 10 failure rate, and I think they'd want that especially from something that was as expensive as the PS3 has been.



A game I'm developing with some friends:

www.xnagg.com/zombieasteroids/publish.htm

It is largely a technical exercise but feedback is appreciated.

ph4nt said:
LOL are people REALLY trying to spin this against the Wii because it's hardware is weaker? truly pathetic.

There has never been a generation where Nintendo hasn't had the most reliable product, it's only natural that it continues. If the graphical prowess of the 360 and PS3 caused higher failure rates, that's a terrible business decision and shows that electronics were not ready for the increase in power.

Too many stupid people in this thread, and the only cure for stupidity is death.

They might try reading before suicide.



In the wilderness we go alone with our new knowledge and strength.

Soriku said:
Generations aren't decided by graphics. In fact, it's only this gen that's been decided by graphics by some people so they can divide the Wii somehow. But the truth is the Wii's still competing, and is getting games currently.

This is a discussion about reliability. You're having a different discussion.