How do ppl know that Uncharted will even be good? >_< demo dosent mean nuttin... look at mirrors edge >_>

Well a lot of whats coming out is sequels, to be honest I don't understand why people are saying Uncharted, it got an 88 ...

Left 4 Dead, Halo 3, Forza, Modern Warfare and Bioshock all scored higher than that ... so surely one of their sequels will do the job, not Uncharted 2.

forza 3 or Uncharted 2

Im sorry, for all the people that are saying Forza.... when has a racing game won GOTY? just asking cause i dont think ever... That also goes for figters...

Are you on crack?

lol ok it will def be good... but GOTY?

Hey I love SFIV but yeah It's not GOTY material, but remember guys It is the highest rated game so far for the year. Even if It's not your favorite It's the highest rated for the year. Ratings don't equate to sales. But keep your predictions coming and maybe in January we'll revisit this topic if I can find it. lol.

SF4 is amazing. If you don't like SF4 challenge me and I'll make you hate it even more ;)

OT Uncharted 2 or perhaps Demon Souls or Splinter Cell perhaps. Any of those games would be lucky to have a fraction of the replay value SF4 has.

so for this thread GOTY = highest rated by critics?

In that case COD:MW2.

My personal GOTY is Demon's Souls right now, though critic score wise DS obviously won't win.

Oh god, I will settle for almost every game listed in this thread.