lestatdark said: @Adjudicator
The same goes for the PES fans that don't seem to find FIFA any better than PES. Different play styles and different expectations of a football game. I can't get into FIFA because of the more arcady feel, the only mode that I really liked in the last two FIFA's was Be a Pro, because it was really well done, and made you feel like you were actually a player. In that aspect, the similar mode in PES 09 felt a bit akward and didn't quite fit with the whole feel of the game. |
To be honest nowadays PES feels much more arcade than FIFA. I always played PES, since ISS on the supernintendo, but really PES starts on the PS1 with ISS Pro, as SNES ISS series was continued by Major A on N64.
ISS Pro for the PS1 was fantastic, heads and shoulders ahead of anything at the time, FIFA did always pretty much suck, with notable exceptions as the 98 Road to the World Cup game that was actually pretty good. Sadly, PES got stuck. FIFA continued to be crap until 08, which showed EA was (very surprisingly) getting it right, not quite for 08 in my opinion though.
FIFA 09 is just better than PES9. As a PES player, I have to say when you first try FIFA09 it feels awkward, which is a normal thing I guess after a lifetime of PES. If you keep digging, you will find a very solid football game. The player physics, the way the collisions among players happen, it's just incredibly better than PES. If you take on the manual control, then the simulation you achieve is nowhere near what PES can achieve. You decide the force and direction of any pass, such is the control that the pass through button becomes useless as you just pass through with the normal pass. In PES on the other hand you just press X and the ball keeps going to the players, doesn't really matter much the direction you apply of the force, things happen too easy, there is little reward. In FIFA09 it's an achievement just to make the ball flow with no mistakes through your defenders. This has an impact on the way you play, it's easy to miss a pass, it tempts you to just clear the ball with a long kick when you are pressed on defense. I could go on and on. In my opinion, PES is much more arcade than FIFA. To all PES players, just give FIFA time, put some time on it and when you go back to PES you will be amazed of the things you can't do. I am leaving aside presentation, sound, comentary, licences...