Great choices Splinter Cell: Conviction looks great.

SMG2 wasn't playable, and honestly, can you really say R&C doesn't deserve it? They're excellent games, and A Crack in Time looks to be no exception

No, it really doesn't. Past ratchet & clank games were no where near as good as main Mario games. Why will this be different from new super mario bros. wii?
Don't get me wrong, ratchet & Clank is a great game, but compared to Mario? Come'on now...

Anyway we all know how super mario galaxy 2 will play, but ok you have a point that it's not on it bc it wasn't playable. But still new super mario bros. wii deserves it imo.

Awwww.....no category for unplayable games so that Last Guardian could get a mention. Oh well

Yeah, they should have something like biggest surprise. Yeah, I just want Metroid on the list XD

I hated Super Mario 64 and I loved the three R&C games I played, so I'd really pick R&C over SM

Yeah, and I don't have a problem with that, but aren't these lists supposed to be objective instead of subjective?

I'm 90% sure that new super mario bros. will get better reviews and better sales(100% sure, but sales say nothing about the quality of a game though)

Playing one of the best platformers ever made with 3 other friends= Too much fun and cussing at each other. 

Well, they should have played both and felt that R&C was better. Which I don't find impossible to believe either

Sounds plausible, but I'm going with my theory that they hate the wii.

Yay for conspiracy theories! Let's forget that they gave SMG the 2007 GOTY!!