What will be your next review?

 no idea, I'm doing retro and regular reviews. 

Do shadow of the comet. Amazing game. Or, continue with Bionic Commando to have a nazi theme for the first reviews. Exploding Hitlers are always funny.

I'd go with...

Wolfenstein 3-D: 8.4
Doom: 8.8
Doom II: Hell on Earth: 10.0
Quake 1: 9.5
Quake 2: 9.0
GoldenEye: 10.0
Perfect Dark: 9.6
Half-Life: 10.0
TimeSplitters 2: 9.0
CounterStrike (betas): 9.2
Halo: 8.7
Half-Life 2: 10.0
CounterStrike Source: 10.0
Halo 2: 9.4
Doom 3: 8.2

And I played one of the Unreal games, and I'd give it a 9.0, but I forgot which one it was.

I know the chronology's a little off, but that's how I'd rate many of the big hitters. I haven't played Halo 3, and I'm barely at the beginning of Metroid Prime 3 right now. I think id and Valve own FPSs, and Rare was up there with the console FPSs like a diamond in the rough for a while. Oh how the mighty have fallen.

I think Wolfenstein is owed mad props for creating the beast, but I think the growth from there to Doom 1 and then Doom 2 was insane and Doom 2 is still my favorite FPS.