Well with 5 rounds, Cnet Somehow has PSP on top. Go figure.

 round: 

Design                                             PSP=   3.7            DSI= 3.3

GAMEPLAY                                        PSP = 3.7             DSI= 5.0

FEATURES                                          PSP= 5.0             DSI= 3.7

PERFORMANCE                                  PSP=  4.0           DSI =  3.3

GAME LIBRARY                                    PSP= 3.3            DSI=  3.7

                                                                 PSP 3.9   TO     DSI 3.8

It's funny the two most important factors, gameplay and library DSI wins but somehow loses to the PSP.

Here's the video, hope someone can embed it please.

http://cnettv.cnet.com/nintendo-dsi-vs-psp-3000/9742-1_53-50071946.html

Yay for more arbitrary numbers.

Weird thing, DS lite won last year.

Is the PSP's library really that close to the DS's? That's pretty impressive.

Should of been 6 rounds, the 6th being about sales then DS would of hammered that.

Probably not but still would of meant something, sales being somehwat equal to popularity, Still the DSi lost because of judges graphics whoreness.

to be fair, the DS is way better than the psp, not because of sales but because of the gameplay aand the pure amount of titles available on the ds.

And how about the Design, The DSi can flip and it looks great, I would of thought DSi would of won that, Midn you it was 0.1 difference so it wasn't like PSP hammered it, just more like PSP was 5mm ( half cm )  ahead of DSi on the finish line in a race.

The PSP looks better though.

Cnet are tech whores. So...

All said.   I have a PSP wouldn't want a DS.

Though DS really should win this.