Good except Cod 4 isnt even close to HL 2. But Gears 1 is way better than gears 2 so i agree with that and everything else

You havent played Soul Calibur against an expert? It also depends on which fighting stance you have with SC series to. But play someone who knows the characters inside out, and decent combos come stringing through.

Agreed there are faster fighters, but I also stated precise. VF5 is good, but the character design is poor. Good fight system though. SSBB is just to casual, well all SSB games are. Alot of good fighters can randomly lose, and I hate that.

I didn't mention VF5 or SSBB.  Look at the video.  It's Arc-2 and Arc-2 dominates SF4 in every aspect but nostalgia.

And no, good fighters can't randomly lose in SSBB unless you're playing with items on.  Get your facts straight.

Near perfect list. Just need Killzone 2 and GT5:P in and It would be near perfect Imo

 Aren't items the whole point of a mario game? Thats like saying turn off items in Mario Kart. The move set is so primative that without items in SSBB I would have got bored. Hey I love ninty, Ive just never liked SSB of any type enough to make it my number 1 fighting game.

About Arc-2, Ive never played it, so cant judge it sorry.

In Red:

Glad to see someone else that holds Condemned in high esteem. I chose that for survival runner up. :)

nope, SF4 is not even as good as SF3 or TvC, so not even close.

According to.. you, I assume?

and 99% of the people who have mastered Capcom fighters.

 I hate 2D fighters so they can all go f' themselves :p