By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Gaming - KillZone2, inFAMOUS, Uncharted 2 > any other 3 exclusives this year

selnor on 14 May 2009
Tbone said:
U forgot White knight chronicles, Demons souls, Ratchet and Clank, Heavy rain :)

 

 WKC unfortunately has bad press from people that have played it. So far as saying it has no art design, battles are horrible and story is weeny. I expect WKC to get 60-70% metacritic when all said and done.

Demon Souls will be good, but score bad. Ninja Blade is right up there with the best Hackers and look at it's Meta score. Sad that ALL review companies now just review on hype. Pathetic. From Software I'll take this moment to say Well done with NB. Fantastic game. :)



Around the Network
TheTruthProphet on 14 May 2009

HALO ODST will EASILY OUTSELL all 3 of those combined & get a higher metacritic score than those 3 aeraged. Mark my words



selnor on 14 May 2009
kowenicki said:
@selnor

agreed Ninja Blade got stupid reviews.

 

 Yeah tell me about it. I'll write a review soon. It's like most reviewers did not play the same game as me. I have finished Ninja Gaiden 2 on Master and I still died on Blade at least 20-40 times on first playthrough. The game is supposed to be over the top boss fights and cutscenes. Guess the reviewers nowadays havent got a brain to work that out. :)



TheSteve on 14 May 2009
ithis said:
TheSteve said:
kowenicki said:
I agree with The Steve...
A vote for TheSteve is a vote for logic...

 

The logic of 2007 if we go by your sig. ;)

 

Other: A bet. Cool.

 

Hey, it's modern in my house...  I've got a bunch of games for 360, my kids play the Wii, and I watch movies on the PS3.  You can't argue with that logic, unless you're secretly living in my home.

 



Believing in the PLAYSTATION®3......IS.......S_A_C_R_I_L_E_G_E

kazad91 on 14 May 2009

from those the only one i find appealing is Uncharted 2, i honestly think Nintendo is having a better year



Around the Network
AussieGecko on 14 May 2009
Kantor said:
AussieGecko said:
Kantor said:
AussieGecko said:
can someone let infamous know of my bet,

The top 3 360 Excl games will beat 3 ps3 excl games.

The Rules
1. Metacritic scores at the end of the year
2. When i say excl as long as it is on only one of the home consoles only, ie Wii, 360, PS3 then it is excl
3. I am doing this because although infamous thinks that he hasnt seen it, he has quoted one of my posts with the rules.
4. Any PS3 games, not just the ones posted, i am almost going to guarantee at least one game will beat them.
5. Excl includes 09, If ps3 is going to get Halo ODST for example in 2010 but 360 in 09, then it is Exclusive for 360 for this year.

I wouldn't mind taking that.

So we are saying all three top metascores combined?

Okay, one last thing. Are we counting XBLA/PSN?

EDIT: One rule I would request is no DLC. That means no Lost and Damned, no Pitt, no Broken Steel, no inevitable GTAIV PS3 expansion.

 

Fair enough, no dlc which means no xbla, in my opinion that hurts my cause, as the 360 will be getting perfect dark soon, hopefully this year but i am going to rely on proper games. The fairest way to do it i would think, you set the terms if you want, in other words what the bet will be for

Okay, sure.

1) If the total metascore of the top five PS3 exclusives is greater than that of the 360's top five, I (Kantor) win. If not, you (AussieGecko) win. If they are equal, it is a tie, and nobody wins.

2) "Exclusives" is defined as "a game not on any other 7th Gen home console. IE, a 360-Wii multiplat is not a 360 exclusive, but a 360- multiplat is. Similarly, MLB 09 (PS3, PSP, PS2) is a PS3 exclusive.

3) Any exclusives released from 1st January to 31st December 2009 will be counted.

4) Games must be exclusive everywhere. That means no FF13.

5) This is being judged, if not obvious already, using Metacritic.

6) Games must be proper retail disc games. ODST counts, Peggle does not.

7) A port of a game with some extra modes is not an exclusive. That means NG Sigma 2 does not count, and neither is MGS4+Oxide, in the 0.00000000000001% chance that it exists.

8) Winner changes loser's sig and avatar for a month. Sig and avatar must abide by forum rules.

9) The bet ends after all exclusive games on both platforms for 2009 have been released, or if both AussieGecko and Kantor agree to end the bet prematurely.

10) If the loser (or winner) is banned when the bet ends, the sig and avatar changing will commence after the ban has ended.

11) A link to this post (or a post containing the final bet) will be displayed in both member's profiles, and if they wish, their sigs.

I think that should cover it. Anything to add?

EDIT: I think we should make it top 5, actually. Gives more accurate results.?

Agreed with that, these are fair terms, just out of curiousity (and sheer laziness) does anyone know the top 5 of ps3 and 360 atm?

 



 

Bet with Conegamer and Doobie_wop 

http://gamrconnect.vgchartz.com/post.php?id=3879752

Vetteman94 on 14 May 2009

Heavy Rain, Heavy Rain, and uhhh, oh yeah Heavy Rain

Because nothing else matters.

@selnor

I agree the Ninja Blade game looked awesome, it is sad the reviewers have resorted to being pricks



AussieGecko on 14 May 2009
<>
TheTruthProphet said:
ODST will EASILY OUTSELL all 3 of those combined & get a metacritic score than those 3 aeraged. Mark my words

 

High 5, but we are not going by sales. This has already been discussed earlier. This is what i think a personal opinion by OP, so not really valid, but made a great contest :)



 

Bet with Conegamer and Doobie_wop 

http://gamrconnect.vgchartz.com/post.php?id=3879752

Vetteman94 on 14 May 2009
AussieGecko said:
Kantor said:
AussieGecko said:
Kantor said:
AussieGecko said:
can someone let infamous know of my bet,

The top 3 360 Excl games will beat 3 ps3 excl games.

The Rules
1. Metacritic scores at the end of the year
2. When i say excl as long as it is on only one of the home consoles only, ie Wii, 360, PS3 then it is excl
3. I am doing this because although infamous thinks that he hasnt seen it, he has quoted one of my posts with the rules.
4. Any PS3 games, not just the ones posted, i am almost going to guarantee at least one game will beat them.
5. Excl includes 09, If ps3 is going to get Halo ODST for example in 2010 but 360 in 09, then it is Exclusive for 360 for this year.

I wouldn't mind taking that.

So we are saying all three top metascores combined?

Okay, one last thing. Are we counting XBLA/PSN?

EDIT: One rule I would request is no DLC. That means no Lost and Damned, no Pitt, no Broken Steel, no inevitable GTAIV PS3 expansion.

 

Fair enough, no dlc which means no xbla, in my opinion that hurts my cause, as the 360 will be getting perfect dark soon, hopefully this year but i am going to rely on proper games. The fairest way to do it i would think, you set the terms if you want, in other words what the bet will be for

Okay, sure.

1) If the total metascore of the top five PS3 exclusives is greater than that of the 360's top five, I (Kantor) win. If not, you (AussieGecko) win. If they are equal, it is a tie, and nobody wins.

2) "Exclusives" is defined as "a game not on any other 7th Gen home console. IE, a 360-Wii multiplat is not a 360 exclusive, but a 360- multiplat is. Similarly, MLB 09 (PS3, PSP, PS2) is a PS3 exclusive.

3) Any exclusives released from 1st January to 31st December 2009 will be counted.

4) Games must be exclusive everywhere. That means no FF13.

5) This is being judged, if not obvious already, using Metacritic.

6) Games must be proper retail disc games. ODST counts, Peggle does not.

7) A port of a game with some extra modes is not an exclusive. That means NG Sigma 2 does not count, and neither is MGS4+Oxide, in the 0.00000000000001% chance that it exists.

8) Winner changes loser's sig and avatar for a month. Sig and avatar must abide by forum rules.

9) The bet ends after all exclusive games on both platforms for 2009 have been released, or if both AussieGecko and Kantor agree to end the bet prematurely.

10) If the loser (or winner) is banned when the bet ends, the sig and avatar changing will commence after the ban has ended.

11) A link to this post (or a post containing the final bet) will be displayed in both member's profiles, and if they wish, their sigs.

I think that should cover it. Anything to add?

EDIT: I think we should make it top 5, actually. Gives more accurate results.?

Agreed with that, these are fair terms, just out of curiousity (and sheer laziness) does anyone know the top 5 of ps3 and 360 atm?

 

If I had to guess then, and this is if they release this year.  

PS3
God of War III
Uncharted 2
Heavy Rain
Killzone 2
Ratchet & Clank Future

360
Alan Wake
Forza 3
Splinter Cell
Halo ODST
????????    <----  Maybe Lost Planet 2,  need a little help on the last one

 



selnor on 14 May 2009

Agreed with that, these are fair terms, just out of curiousity (and sheer laziness) does anyone know the top 5 of ps3 and 360 atm?

 

AussieGecko said:
Kantor said:
AussieGecko said:
Kantor said:
AussieGecko said:

 

 

Agreed with that, these are fair terms, just out of curiousity (and sheer laziness) does anyone know the top 5 of ps3 and 360 atm?

 

 Well

Top 5 360 is:

Gears 1 = 94, Halo 3 = 94, Gears 2 = 93, Mass Effect = 91, Forza 2 = 90

Top 5 PS3 is:

LBP = 95, MGS4 = 94, KZ2 = 91, MLB 09 The Show = 90, R&C: FTOD = 89.

Thats the top 5 all time.

For 2009 it's as follows.

PS3:

KZ2 = 91, MLB 09: The show = 90, Flower = 87, Yakuza 3 = 84, Singstar Queen = 76

360:

Halo Wars = 82, Battlestations Pacific =  77, Star Ocean TLH = 76, Race Pro = 72, Ninja Blade 68.

These are based on Metacritic scores, and do NOT contain DLC games. They also are ONLY games Exclusive to each console.