Rate the above users game collection

Gameplay:

1. Check out the above users game collection

2. Post the top 3 games in the users collection and the bottom 3 (based on your personal opinion)

3. Give an overall rating of the users collection with a rating of, or between, 1-10

Example:

John Doe rates my collection:

+ FFVII, Xenogears, Bioshock

- Dragon's Lair, Singstar, Buzz! Pop Quiz

9/10

And the next user rates John Doe's collection

Have fun, and treat each other with respect.

Beoulve's collection:

+ Mass Effect, Lost Odyssey, FF X
- Pokemon yellow, Phoenix Wright, Chip'n Dale

9/10 excellent collection

Esa-Petteri's collection:

+ Mass Effect, FFVII, FFX
- Hexic, GT4, Madden NFL 09

I'm not a fan of sports and racing games, but still a stellar collection:
9/10

Esa Petteri's collection

+ Gran Turismo 4, Call of Duty 4, Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas
- Blue Dragon, Eternal Sonota, Too Human

8/10, not too shabby

coolestguyever colection

+fall out 2, resistance, oblivion
- madden, NHL, uno

7/10 average

emilie autumn's collection

+ FF VII, VIII, IX

- super mario world: yoshi's island,mario&sonic at the olympics,mario party 2

6/10 ... a lot of games, but just not my cup of tea. No offence. :P

edit:

This thread made me update my game collection a bit. Still quite a few games to update. :)

emilie autumn's collection:

+ Paper Mario, Donkey Kong 64, Final Fantasy VIII

- Mario Kart Wii, Sonic and the Secret Rings, Super Paper Mario

6/10 (There is not a lot of variety)

emilie autumn's collection (would do Esa-Petteri's but he's already been done):

+Dragon Quest V, Wind Waker, Sin and Punishment
-Dawn of the New World, Tales of Symphonia, general lack of any Western games!

6/10

The games that are here are good, but this collection could use some diversification.

emilie autumn

+ FFVII, FFIII, Silent Hill
- Mario & Sonic @ the Olympics, Mario Kart WII, WWF WrestleMania 2000

Awesome collection, lots of classic old school titles:
9/10

lot of late posts, including myself... this can become a probably (uhm, already has I guess)