I agree with you on Folklore, Resistance 2, Resistance and Motorstorm (though the last two were standout launch titles, so it's understandable that they scored so highly), but the rest of those games received 9's and 10's across the board.

You might as well say you don't trust reviews in general...

And that right there is the key. Out of those games above, Red marked are ones i would give 9/10 blue are ones i'd give 8.5-9.0

Resistance because it became better and better until it got really awesome I thought the story was going to end like 3 times before it did lol.  Resistance 2 because of all the play modes and durability. Though i would have liked them to write the story differently.. It was a little lacking storywise.

If you'd had motorstorm pacific rift up there i'd given it a 9. Definetly. It's a truly remarkable offroad racing game and i've spent many hours on it. The original.. well while it was certainly good it had a few issues. The lack of splitscreen hurt it (since it's a racing game it kinda needs this) and you blew up too quickly. Like if you looked at a rock funny you'd go boom lol.

Killzone 2 because frankly. It's one of the best first person shooters ever, and one of the only shooters to draw me into the online mode seriously since the first call of duty.

Little big planet because of everything it contains. The tons and tons of content and options.

Metal Gear Solid 4. Because, even without having played the previous games (have watched the retrospectives though) this is one of the best games ever if you ask me. It's epic on so amazingly many levels.

Uncharted because it's such an incredible experience... Immersive, fluid and fun. It has such advanced animation systems it brings most other games to shame. The look and feel of it simply draws you into this hollywood experience.

Only played the demos of valkyria and folklore.. but i definetly think valkyria is up there if the demo is anything to go by. Folklore i'm unsure off because it's been so long since i've played the demo of it.

In either case. My point is that everyone has different opinions and the reason ign has 3 different reviewers on each game is so that you can get 3 perspectives of the game. They all seem very positive on this game and i have to admit it does sound pretty damn awesome. Just because you might have different opinions on how good games are, does not nullify everyone elses opinons :p

I just don't trust IGN for PS3 games. Believe it or not, I trust Edge for PS3 games most of the time...

@everyone, this is my opinion. I'm not saying IGN or PS3 games suck. I just don't trust them when it comes to PS3 games.

@Mirson you like R2 right?

I like it, but it's nowhere near 9.5. Same with Folklore.

Pretty surprising.

I still remember the early days of inFamous, and everyone thought it would probably amount to nothing. Once info started coming through more people became believers. Even myself thought this game was gonna be crap and now I am getting it day one!

It seems to me Edge give good games bad scores and give bad games good scores.  I think Gamespot is the best.

I doubt they pay developers to make shitty games :p haha !

I mean when paying developers it's usually because you expect the end result to be good... atleast i assume it is.

The highlighted. So you like them because they give ps3 games bad scores ? well it would fit with your posting "profile"