By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - General - Most Demanding Sport?

I'm going with F1 racing:

One question that people who don’t follow motor racing often ask is “how fit are the drivers?” If F1’s not your thing, it’s easy to assume racinga Formula 1 car is no more strenuous than driving on the road.

Toyota team doctor Ricardo Ceccarelli gives some extraordinary insight into the punishing forces an F1 driver is subject to - and how fit they need to be

There is no other sport in the world which compares to the demands Formula 1 puts on the heart.

The heart rate of a top driver can average over 180bpm for a race distance of 90 minutes or more. This is huge and no other sport keeps a heart rate so high for such a long time.

On top of that there is a lot of muscle work for the whole body - heavy work for neck muscles to cope with the G forces, high loads on legs and arms and good lumbar strength to stabilise the body. A normal person could do two or three laps in a Formula 1 car under those stresses before physically they couldn’t continue.

What I often think makes F1 different from many other sports is the demands it places on a drivers’ concentration. In football, for example, a player is always paying attention to what is going on and often moving around – but his activity on the ball is occasional.

In F1 the driver is working all the time and the slightest misjudgement on the controls can cause a crash or a spin. Ceccarelli explains:

The demand on the muscles is important but the load on the brain is amazing. Formula 1 is a sport where the brain has to be working hard for the whole race.

In tennis you have a break every few seconds, in boxing you break every three minutes, in shooting you break all the time. This means a Formula 1 driver’s brain is working in a different way. When you compare a Formula 1 driver’s brain to an average person, the way it works is completely different.

When a driver is racing he is driving differently to a qualifying lap, which puts more intense physical strain on him. In qualifying a driver is right on the limit, always very close to a mistake and his heart can be beating 50bpm faster than a normal racing lap. This shows the body is doing a massive amount of work, which is possible to sustain for a few minutes but not a whole race.

At Sepang two weeks ago we saw Fernando Alonso compete despite suffering an ear infection. What kind of effect might that have had on his performance?

The affect [of illness] on the driver is really subtle and difficult to see.

Before I worked with Toyota, I saw a driver who was starting the race after having a very bad infection for four days. He lost a lot of fluids and he arrived on Sunday feeling really bad, but he had to start. He told me after the race that he felt he could collapse at any point but he finished in the top six because he had a good car.

When a driver who is normally super fit is sick, he is likely to be four tenths - maximum half a second - slower than usual in the race.

http://www.f1fanatic.co.uk/2009/04/21/how-fit-is-an-f1-driver/

F1 drivers can experience forces of up to 4.5G's in the turns!

I'd add more, but the article does a great job of explaining everything.  The comments on the page are a great read as well.  My favore, though, was this one:

“There are only three sports: bullfighting, motor racing, and mountaineering; all the rest are merely games.” - Ernest Hemingway



Around the Network


Real Football (not Gridiron).

You have to be a freakin Spartan when it comes to Stamina.
There's a reason why top trained players falls over and dies of heart attack.

Also let's not forget all the dangerous elbows causing fatal blows to the head. All the slide tackles and lack of protection. In football you have to be so aware of everything going on around you if you're gonna have a chance not getting hurt or wounded. It's a demanding sport requiring lots of technique and training. As is Rugby.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_footballers_who_died_while_playing

 



???? Should I read this? Judgeing by thread title no. Football is brutal. You break everything!



Tag:I'm not bias towards Nintendo. You just think that way (Admin note - it's "biased".  Not "bias")
(killeryoshis note - Who put that there ?)
Switch is 9th generation. Everyone else is playing on last gen systems! UPDATE: This is no longer true. 2nd UPDATE: I have no Switch 2. I am now behind

Biggest pikmin fan on VGchartz I won from a voting poll
I am not a nerd. I am enthusiast.  EN-THU-SI-AST!
Do Not Click here or else I will call on the eye of shining justice on you. 

GamingChartzFTW said:

Real Football (not Gridiron).

You have to be a freakin Spartan when it comes to stamina.
There's a reason why top trained players falls over and dies of heart failure/heart attack,

 

"The heart rate of a top driver can average over 180bpm for a race distance of 90 minutes or more. This is huge and no other sport keeps a heart rate so high for such a long time."

There's no let down in racing, ever.  You're brain is going all out constantly.  You're driving on the edge all the time, and mistakes are not an option, as they don't just lead to giving a goal up, but crashing.  Plus, they don't get a break every 45 minutes. ;)


@Killeryoshis: I'm a big (American) Football fan, and I think it pales in comparison to F1 racing.  It's a great read.



amount of skill needed. Golf by far.

demanding on the body, would probably be a marathon runner.

edit- disregard that.  haha.  Water polo >>>>>>>>>> everything



Around the Network

polo would be up there. You need to ride a horse and play a game with sticks at the same time. Crazy.



FaRmLaNd said:
polo would be up there. You need to ride a horse and play a game with sticks at the same time. Crazy.

 

I can't say for sure, as I don't have much experience with horses, but that seems to only have the concentration part of things without the physical endurance part.  If any horse-based sport can make an argument for being super-demanding, it's jousting if only because of how painful it must be.



Ironman triathlon (4km swim, 180km on a bike and a marathon back to back). It doesn't require concentration in the same way that Formula 1 does, but the amount of mental toughness, not to mention physical conditioning required is astounding to me.



hsrob said:
Ironman triathlon (4km swim, 180km on a bike and a marathon back to back). It doesn't require concentration in the same way that Formula 1 does, but the amount of mental toughness, not to mention physical conditioning required is astounding to me.

 

Ironically, Jenson Button, an F1 driver, participates in triathlons.

http://www.timesonline.co.uk/tol/life_and_style/health/traineo/exercise/article4032674.ece



tarheel91 said:
hsrob said:
Ironman triathlon (4km swim, 180km on a bike and a marathon back to back). It doesn't require concentration in the same way that Formula 1 does, but the amount of mental toughness, not to mention physical conditioning required is astounding to me.

 

Ironically, Jenson Button, an F1 driver, participates in triathlons.

http://www.timesonline.co.uk/tol/life_and_style/health/traineao/exercise/article4032674.ece

Incidentally that's how Lance Armstrong started out, but Button only did a sissy little triathlon:P  When talking about the MOST demanding i'm only referring to Ironman Triathlon.

edit: but i have heard before about F1 drivers, Schumacher was supposed to be a machine and i know Mark Webber is into long distance adventure racing.