By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - General - Arguments Against God

Here's my argument against God.  The idea came to me as a teenager while I was 'compelled' to go to church with my parents and learn about the stories of the Bible.  I found it funny that the personalities of God and man are so similar, even though God was suppose to be infinately more powerful and knowledgable than man.

Lets assume God exists and that God created the universe and is all powerful.  Man is more powerful than an ant, yet nothing compared to the difference between God and man.  A man puts ants in an ant farm, feeds them, watches over them, but he requests that the ants pay homage to him in return for his deeds.  The man feels that the ants disobey him and dont pay proper respect to him, so he takes the ants out and tortures them horribly.

We would all say that the man is being ridiculous, yet when we look at God we think his actions are not so ridiculous.  Why would a God want people to worship him?  Why would he want to reward or punish inferior creatures in such a way that is described in the Bible?  Why is God angry, or jealous?

The answer is that God was created by man, and naturally man gave God human-like characteristics, just like we give animals and other mythical beings human-like characteristics in other man made stories.  This explains why God has the personality of a human king in 5,000 BC.  At that time men desired to be worshipped, they were very angry, jealous, and vengeful against others, and they ruled with a iron-fist.  Actions God commanded of his Old Testament followers are considered harse and ridiculous by today's standards, but were on par with mankind at that time.



Around the Network

I don’t understand, your saying there cant be a god b/c he acts like a man, but how do you know its not man acting like god?



 

Can god tell the difference between butter and "I can't believe it's not butter"?



Argument against theistic god of religions: No proof

Argument against a loving god that created everything: Suffering

Argument against the unknowable deist god: No proof



mesoteto said:
I don’t understand, your saying there cant be a god b/c he acts like a man, but how do you know its not man acting like god?

My argument is: Man-made stories give animals and mythical beings characteristics of human beings.  God has characteristics of a human being.  God was made by man.

I hope man isnt acting like God :)



Around the Network
ManusJustus said:
mesoteto said:
I don’t understand, your saying there cant be a god b/c he acts like a man, but how do you know its not man acting like god?

My argument is: Man-made stories give animals and mythical beings characteristics of human beings.  God has characteristics of a human being.  God was made by man.

I hope man isnt acting like God :)

 

 

I hope that too, otherwise god is one messed up mother fucker.



SamuelRSmith said:
Can god tell the difference between butter and "I can't believe it's not butter"?

 

Lets hope he doesn't accidentally send everyone to hell.

 

"I can't believe they're not all sinners!"

 

:P



yep, all religions are man made, so IF any diety exists, it wont be like the deitys of any man made religion, as man cannot be divine.



SciFiBoy said:
yep, all religions are man made, so IF any diety exists, it wont be like the deitys of any man made religion, as man cannot be divine.

 

Speak for yourself. 



SamuelRSmith said:
SciFiBoy said:
yep, all religions are man made, so IF any diety exists, it wont be like the deitys of any man made religion, as man cannot be divine.

 

Speak for yourself. 

 

lol, yeah, any man claiming to be divine is either Joking, Insane or Lying.