By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Gaming - PS3 is Not More Powerful than Xbox 360, says game Dev!

NNN2004 on 09 April 2009
WereKitten said:
NNN2004 said:
justinian said:
Prove it.

 

 most of the all the multiplat games prove it ;)

Wrong logic, false data :)

- if _all_ multiplat games were better on the 360 than on the PS3, this would still not prove that a game could not be made on the PS3 that can't be done on the 360. Thus it would not disprove the thesis that the PS3 is more powerful. Wrong logic.

- not all multiplat games are better on the 360 ( go browse the Digital Foundry website ). False data.

The closing smiley is alright, though, and the syntax correct :)

 

corrected ;)

 



Around the Network
WereKitten on 09 April 2009
NNN2004 said:
WereKitten said:
NNN2004 said:
justinian said:
Prove it.

 

 most of the all the multiplat games prove it ;)

Wrong logic, false data :)

- if _all_ multiplat games were better on the 360 than on the PS3, this would still not prove that a game could not be made on the PS3 that can't be done on the 360. Thus it would not disprove the thesis that the PS3 is more powerful. Wrong logic.

- not all multiplat games are better on the 360 ( go browse the Digital Foundry website ). False data.

The closing smiley is alright, though, and the syntax correct :)

 

corrected ;)

 

Good, now you only have wrong logic :)

 



"All you need in life is ignorance and confidence; then success is sure." - Mark Twain

"..." - Gordon Freeman

NNN2004 on 09 April 2009
WereKitten said:
NNN2004 said:
WereKitten said:
NNN2004 said:
justinian said:
Prove it.

 

 most of the all the multiplat games prove it ;)

Wrong logic, false data :)

- if _all_ multiplat games were better on the 360 than on the PS3, this would still not prove that a game could not be made on the PS3 that can't be done on the 360. Thus it would not disprove the thesis that the PS3 is more powerful. Wrong logic.

- not all multiplat games are better on the 360 ( go browse the Digital Foundry website ). False data.

The closing smiley is alright, though, and the syntax correct :)

 

corrected ;)

 

Good, now you only have wrong logic :)

 

lol

 



iron_megalith on 09 April 2009
YNNN2004 said:
numonex said:
This sounds very close to the truth. All we get in other threads is articles on Sony spreading mindless propaganda on how much powerful PS3 "potentially" is than the XBox 360.

yah and whats more annoying is some sony fans say that its more powerful than the PC!

 

 

yah whats really more annoying is that some people really don't seem to realize the same stench coming from their side.

 

Moral lesson:

Blind Sony/PS3 fanboy = Blind (Insert console/company name) fanboy.



Staude on 09 April 2009
Staude said:
lanjiaona said:


Jason Booth, a game developer who has worked on both Guitar Hero games and Rock Band, has posted some interesting comments on his blog regarding "PS3 misconceptions and spin."

"I read various game forums from time to time, and often see gamers complaining about 'lazy ports' to the PS3. They often mention how the PS3 is the most powerful game console and blame developers working on the console for doing a bad job. Sony has all of these people duped by impressive marketing spin... ports to the PS3 will never be as good as their 360 counter parts, and ...most PS3 exclusives will likely continue to suck," he says.

 

Lol his games are likely to continue to suck.

 

Anyways his full of bullshit. Look at it's exclusives. Hes completely forgetting the processor because it's usually not used in graphical applications. And i also think in general that's the biggest issue. Sony is one of the few companies that uses the cell for everything, while a lot of developers just try to dump data over in a regular manner.

 

This is what santa monica is doing with God of War 3.

http://www.tilander.org/aurora/comp/gdc2009_Tilander_Filippov_SPU.pdf

I'm going to quote myself for the guys who said he was speaking the truth. You musth have missed my last post where it shows how the spus also renders for the gpu. Thers a link for a full presentation on how santa monica makes their ps3 game(gow3) ... I got it from squilliams thread on the subject. It's quite interesting.

 



Check out my game about moles ^

Around the Network
Staude on 09 April 2009
WereKitten said:
NNN2004 said:
WereKitten said:
NNN2004 said:
justinian said:
Prove it.

 

 most of the all the multiplat games prove it ;)

Wrong logic, false data :)

- if _all_ multiplat games were better on the 360 than on the PS3, this would still not prove that a game could not be made on the PS3 that can't be done on the 360. Thus it would not disprove the thesis that the PS3 is more powerful. Wrong logic.

- not all multiplat games are better on the 360 ( go browse the Digital Foundry website ). False data.

The closing smiley is alright, though, and the syntax correct :)

 

corrected ;)

 

Good, now you only have wrong logic :)

 

Actually he managed to correct himself and maintain improper grammer. It says "Most of the the.."

 



Check out my game about moles ^

786_ali on 09 April 2009
Staude said:
Staude said:
lanjiaona said:


Jason Booth, a game developer who has worked on both Guitar Hero games and Rock Band, has posted some interesting comments on his blog regarding "PS3 misconceptions and spin."

"I read various game forums from time to time, and often see gamers complaining about 'lazy ports' to the PS3. They often mention how the PS3 is the most powerful game console and blame developers working on the console for doing a bad job. Sony has all of these people duped by impressive marketing spin... ports to the PS3 will never be as good as their 360 counter parts, and ...most PS3 exclusives will likely continue to suck," he says.

 

Lol his games are likely to continue to suck.

 

Anyways his full of bullshit. Look at it's exclusives. Hes completely forgetting the processor because it's usually not used in graphical applications. And i also think in general that's the biggest issue. Sony is one of the few companies that uses the cell for everything, while a lot of developers just try to dump data over in a regular manner.

 

This is what santa monica is doing with God of War 3.

http://www.tilander.org/aurora/comp/gdc2009_Tilander_Filippov_SPU.pdf

I'm going to quote myself for the guys who said he was speaking the truth. You musth have missed my last post where it shows how the spus also renders for the gpu. Thers a link for a full presentation on how santa monica makes their ps3 game(gow3) ... I got it from squilliams thread on the subject. It's quite interesting.

 

Complex stuff, but, from what I understand, it shows that the ps3 is more powerful

 



Initiating social expirement #928719281

Staude on 09 April 2009
786_ali said:
Staude said:
Staude said:
lanjiaona said:


Jason Booth, a game developer who has worked on both Guitar Hero games and Rock Band, has posted some interesting comments on his blog regarding "PS3 misconceptions and spin."

"I read various game forums from time to time, and often see gamers complaining about 'lazy ports' to the PS3. They often mention how the PS3 is the most powerful game console and blame developers working on the console for doing a bad job. Sony has all of these people duped by impressive marketing spin... ports to the PS3 will never be as good as their 360 counter parts, and ...most PS3 exclusives will likely continue to suck," he says.

 

Lol his games are likely to continue to suck.

 

Anyways his full of bullshit. Look at it's exclusives. Hes completely forgetting the processor because it's usually not used in graphical applications. And i also think in general that's the biggest issue. Sony is one of the few companies that uses the cell for everything, while a lot of developers just try to dump data over in a regular manner.

 

This is what santa monica is doing with God of War 3.

http://www.tilander.org/aurora/comp/gdc2009_Tilander_Filippov_SPU.pdf

I'm going to quote myself for the guys who said he was speaking the truth. You musth have missed my last post where it shows how the spus also renders for the gpu. Thers a link for a full presentation on how santa monica makes their ps3 game(gow3) ... I got it from squilliams thread on the subject. It's quite interesting.

 

Complex stuff, but, from what I understand, it shows that the ps3 is more powerful

 

Not only that. It shows what sony has said all along. The spus can really be used for everything. :P

 



Check out my game about moles ^

HappySqurriel on 09 April 2009
786_ali said:
Staude said:
Staude said:
lanjiaona said:


Jason Booth, a game developer who has worked on both Guitar Hero games and Rock Band, has posted some interesting comments on his blog regarding "PS3 misconceptions and spin."

"I read various game forums from time to time, and often see gamers complaining about 'lazy ports' to the PS3. They often mention how the PS3 is the most powerful game console and blame developers working on the console for doing a bad job. Sony has all of these people duped by impressive marketing spin... ports to the PS3 will never be as good as their 360 counter parts, and ...most PS3 exclusives will likely continue to suck," he says.

 

Lol his games are likely to continue to suck.

 

Anyways his full of bullshit. Look at it's exclusives. Hes completely forgetting the processor because it's usually not used in graphical applications. And i also think in general that's the biggest issue. Sony is one of the few companies that uses the cell for everything, while a lot of developers just try to dump data over in a regular manner.

 

This is what santa monica is doing with God of War 3.

http://www.tilander.org/aurora/comp/gdc2009_Tilander_Filippov_SPU.pdf

I'm going to quote myself for the guys who said he was speaking the truth. You musth have missed my last post where it shows how the spus also renders for the gpu. Thers a link for a full presentation on how santa monica makes their ps3 game(gow3) ... I got it from squilliams thread on the subject. It's quite interesting.

 

Complex stuff, but, from what I understand, it shows that the ps3 is more powerful

 

 

If that is what you "understand" you don't really understand at all ...

What it essentially says is that before they took advantage of the SPEs the framerate was dramatically worse than when they took advantage of the SPEs.



786_ali on 09 April 2009
HappySqurriel said:
786_ali said:
Staude said:
Staude said:
lanjiaona said:


Jason Booth, a game developer who has worked on both Guitar Hero games and Rock Band, has posted some interesting comments on his blog regarding "PS3 misconceptions and spin."

"I read various game forums from time to time, and often see gamers complaining about 'lazy ports' to the PS3. They often mention how the PS3 is the most powerful game console and blame developers working on the console for doing a bad job. Sony has all of these people duped by impressive marketing spin... ports to the PS3 will never be as good as their 360 counter parts, and ...most PS3 exclusives will likely continue to suck," he says.

 

Lol his games are likely to continue to suck.

 

Anyways his full of bullshit. Look at it's exclusives. Hes completely forgetting the processor because it's usually not used in graphical applications. And i also think in general that's the biggest issue. Sony is one of the few companies that uses the cell for everything, while a lot of developers just try to dump data over in a regular manner.

 

This is what santa monica is doing with God of War 3.

http://www.tilander.org/aurora/comp/gdc2009_Tilander_Filippov_SPU.pdf

I'm going to quote myself for the guys who said he was speaking the truth. You musth have missed my last post where it shows how the spus also renders for the gpu. Thers a link for a full presentation on how santa monica makes their ps3 game(gow3) ... I got it from squilliams thread on the subject. It's quite interesting.

 

Complex stuff, but, from what I understand, it shows that the ps3 is more powerful

 

 

If that is what you "understand" you don't really understand at all ...

What it essentially says is that before they took advantage of the SPEs the framerate was dramatically worse than when they took advantage of the SPEs.

If that's what it means then, yes, I didn't understand very much :p

 



Initiating social expirement #928719281