I would really love to try Deadly Creatures and Mushroom Men, but I can't find anywere to rent them!

OT: Okami (of all platforms, in FACT), and to add to everyone else; Wii Music,

The Godfather

Williams Pinball Hall of Fame

Kororinpa: Marble Mania (the 2007 one, I have not yet picked up the new one, Marble Saga)

http://www.amazon.com/Kororinpa-Marble-Mania-Nintendo-Wii/dp/B000N0WBMM/ref=sr_1_12?ie=UTF8&s=videogames&qid=1238534678&sr=8-12

The Godfather for me as well. It's surprising even to myself that I, as a matter of fact, return to this game more often than to, say, SMG or LOZ:TP. It's all in the controls!

I am not a huge fan of sandbox games, but the controls on the Godfather are OUTSTANDING! It really is amazing to punch, choke and throw your victims. A must play (or rent) if you missed it.

My two (Williams Pinball Hall of Fame, Kororinpa: Marble Mania) are all about the controls as well. MOH heroes 2 could be on this as well for that reason. The controls for the scope, or for machine gun turrets and bazookas are done phenomenally well.