I'm basing my info on the IGN release dates as they stand from yesturday, 9/3. Things can change; I know. My differentiation between genres may not suit your style perfectly; so fine. I will not be including Playstation 2 because it's last gen, so too bad. Do the work yourself if it's that critical.

Now that all of that is out of the way, here's the point. It's hard to say which system is always the best, because sales do not necessarily entail quality, and gems can pop up on even the most awful of consoles. I'm gonna go genre by genre and show the fall lineup. You guys then discuss who rules in that area. If the release dates get updated by new games added or pushed into next fall, we can reconvene and decide again what that means for each console. I have taken a few liberties by not adding any games specifically for children, such as Spongebob and Ben 10, and will not include any games that have to do with hunting because I figure no one wants to argue over that anyways. If I'm offending any hunting game fans, too bad. Spend your money more wisely in the future. So without further ado...

 

XBOX 360
Date	Game Title	Sub Genre
25-Sep-07	World Series of Poker 2008	Gambling
16-Oct-07	Chessmaster: Grandmaster Edition	Board Game
29-Oct-07	Guitar Hero III: Legends of Rock	Music
30-Oct-07	Viva Pinata: Party Animals	Mini Game
1-Nov-07	Scene It?	Trivia
20-Nov-07	Rock Band	Music

PS3
Date	Game Title	Sub Genre
6-Sep-07	High Stakes on the Vegas Strip: Poker Edition	Gambling
25-Sep-07	World Series of Poker 2008	Gambling
29-Oct-07	Guitar Hero III: Legends of Rock	Music
13-Nov-07	SingStar	Music
20-Nov-07	Rock Band	Music

Wii
Date	Game Title	Sub Genre
18-Sep-07	Mercury Meltdown Revolution	Puzzle
25-Sep-07	Dance Dance Revolution: Hottest Party	Dance
5-Oct-07	Pinball Hall of Fame: The Williams Collection	Pinball
16-Oct-07	Octomania	Puzzle
23-Oct-07	Luxor: Pharaoh's Challenge	Puzzle
22-Oct-07	EA Playground	Mini Games
29-Oct-07	Guitar Hero III: Legends of Rock	Music
30-Oct-07	Dancing With The Stars	Dance
5-Nov-07	Game Party	Mini Games
13-Nov-07	Jenga	Board Game
13-Nov-07	Rayman Raving Rabbids 2	Mini Games
13-Nov-07	Smartypants	Trivia

Now this here is the Wii's supposedly new market. Obviously they dominate in quantity here. No other consoles have any announced puzzle games coming out this fall. But do remember that Live and PSN may still release some over the network. Super Puzzle Fighter II Turbo missed the list because it was released a day before in August, but it's close enough to be added back in I suppose. In that case, it trumps every other puzzle game...combined. as far as mini game collections, Wii has Rayman Raving Rabbids 2 and some odds and ends collections. 360 has Viva Pinata, but Rabbids is absolutely insane and will take that game out and chew on it's fluffy heart. Wii is however missing a big release in Rock Band. Luckily it'll have Guitar Hero III, but Rock Band still stings. For those who love karaoke, Singstar is coming out for PS3. Overall, Wii has the best range of casual games, spanning many different sub genres. Unless you can't live without Rock Band, Wii is where it's at. Bring on the Rabbids!

Wii wins again! Man lets face it. At the end of 2007 the Wii will obviously have the best games. Nintendo can make a freakin' killing if they could only follow up with the consoles needed to sell.

IMO, even if Nintendo were to ship at least 1.5 million Wiis worldwide every month from now till Feb. 2008, they'd still sell out from the ever increasing demand and because of all of the good games. I know I'll get one eventually.

Oh and Onyxmeth, I love these posts by the way. And welcome to the site too as someone already mentioned.

regin2005 said: Oh and Onyxmeth, I love these posts by the way. And welcome to the site too as someone already mentioned.

 Thanks forthe welcome. I just get tired of people saying this or that about a system based on a few games. This shows who's really owning in each category. A fan of sports and racing games will probably tell you the Wii is trash while platform and adventure fans will flock to the Wii obviously. Once you break it all down, you can see that even systems like PS3 that just recieved the bad reviews from Lair can understand that it's only one game and will not ultimately affect a lineup that they are doing pretty well in, especially in shooters, which is usually owned by 360.

The Wii definitely wins this category. Onyxmeth, I have to say that this is a really good idea.

Are you going to do which one has Best Fall-line up Category=Everything?

Where's MySims for Wii? I thought for sure it would count as a casual game. ~_~

Quantity Wii will always win...

Quality. I think there might be some surprises from 360 and PS3... Both announced board games... Scene It? and Buzz quiz TV... Viva Pinata Party Animals is getting good feedback. SingStar looks strong. Rock Bands has a lot of potential.

So, to me, this is going to be the too close to call category.

In before, "I didn't even need to read the list of games, Wii wins."

Wii wins hands down

Mercury Meltdown (and its budget price is a plus)
Rayman Raving Rabbids 2
Guitar Hero III: Legends of Rock
Dance Dance Revolution: Hottest Party

and then there are whole load of party games from every 3rd party.