Lets pretend that we all have children and pretend that they've reached the age you can start showing them Star Wars. What order do you show them in?
The AVGN recently did a review of the Star Wars movies and in his 2nd part he asks what order would you show these movies to your kids.
Do you start with episode IV as you more than likely did so that Vader is a badass villain and you get one of the best movie twists ever or do you start with episode I and make Vader the tragic character?
It really is a good question I think and one I don't think I have the answer to yet. If I had to give an answer right this moment I would probably say episodes IV-V and then I-III but the idea of watching them I-VI for the first time is interesting.
-edit-
Might as well embed the videos