By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Gaming - Western developed JRPG - what if?

Remember Silver?
Didn't sell very well, unfortunetly...



This is invisible text!

Around the Network
Killergran said:
Remember Silver?
Didn't sell very well, unfortunetly...

Actually, it sold close to 500K according to g4's top 5 worst RPGs video so I'd say that it sold alright for a JRPG type game on the PC.  Anachronox, on the other hand, bombed when it was released and was one of the reasons besides Daikatana's sales faliure that Ion Storm closed down.

 



Ah yes Silver. I loved the concept of this game much more than Diablo´s, but alas it was plagued by bugs and broken party members control mechanics...



Riachu said:

The problem Japanese developers seem to have is that JRPGs are still primarily aimed at teenagers and unforunately, the average age of gamers is 33 in the West. Also, the stories tend to be cliched and writing also tends to be embarrassingly poor with Star Ocean being the most recent example.

 

 Even though Lost Odyessy got mixed reviews, I found it refreshingly mature. The dialogue and voice acting was among the best I've seen in a game. Too bad the play mechanics were the same old same old.

Western RPGs are moving twoards single hero first person, while the jrpg are multi-party with a heavy emphasis on inter party communication. Or as I put it, they like to bolt on a dating sim onto ever jrpg they make.

Which makes me think, Bioware titles such as KOTOR and Mass Effect should have appealed to the Japanese.



Yet, today, America's leaders are reenacting every folly that brought these great powers [Russia, Germany, and Japan] to ruin -- from arrogance and hubris, to assertions of global hegemony, to imperial overstretch, to trumpeting new 'crusades,' to handing out war guarantees to regions and countries where Americans have never fought before. We are piling up the kind of commitments that produced the greatest disasters of the twentieth century.
 — Pat Buchanan – A Republic, Not an Empire

Tyrannical said:
Riachu said:

The problem Japanese developers seem to have is that JRPGs are still primarily aimed at teenagers and unforunately, the average age of gamers is 33 in the West. Also, the stories tend to be cliched and writing also tends to be embarrassingly poor with Star Ocean being the most recent example.

 

 Even though Lost Odyessy got mixed reviews, I found it refreshingly mature. The dialogue and voice acting was among the best I've seen in a game. Too bad the play mechanics were the same old same old.

Western RPGs are moving twoards single hero first person, while the jrpg are multi-party with a heavy emphasis on inter party communication. Or as I put it, they like to bolt on a dating sim onto ever jrpg they make.

Which makes me think, Bioware titles such as KOTOR and Mass Effect should have appealed to the Japanese.

On topic of dating sims, yup... I was very surprised to see Carth hit on my female character in KoToR... it's the first time I ever saw something like that in a game.. it sure added depth.

 



Around the Network
Tyrannical said:
Riachu said:

The problem Japanese developers seem to have is that JRPGs are still primarily aimed at teenagers and unforunately, the average age of gamers is 33 in the West. Also, the stories tend to be cliched and writing also tends to be embarrassingly poor with Star Ocean being the most recent example.

 

 Even though Lost Odyessy got mixed reviews, I found it refreshingly mature. The dialogue and voice acting was among the best I've seen in a game. Too bad the play mechanics were the same old same old.

Western RPGs are moving twoards single hero first person, while the jrpg are multi-party with a heavy emphasis on inter party communication. Or as I put it, they like to bolt on a dating sim onto ever jrpg they make.

Which makes me think, Bioware titles such as KOTOR and Mass Effect should have appealed to the Japanese.

 

Lost Odyssey is an exception rather than the rule.

 

KOTOR and Mass Effect would not appeal to the Japanese.  RPGs with sci-fi settings tend to bomb in Japan unless they have an anime influence like Star Ocean or Phantasy Star.