^We know that you have your evidence and are trying to prove that KZ2 doesn't match up to the other two but I can tell you it easily does.
Reviews aren't all that accurate you know, look at GTA4 for example. And if Halo 3 wasn't called 'Halo 3' it wouldn't of got that 93%. I mean Halo 3 is one of the greats I played but won't be 2% better than KZ2 while I'm still alive:p

KZ2 based on the MP ive played on halo 3 at my mates including gears horde mode & MP KZ2s MP alone feels funnier :]

This.

Nothing can touch Halo. Halo is legendary.

Between KZ2 and Gears, Killzone has better grafix but Gears is more badass, is higher on Gamerankings, has bigger sales and he will get his own Hollywood movie.

1st - Halo 3
2nd - Killzone 2
3rd - Gears 2
4th - Cod 4

imo, nothing can touch the amount of fun that Halo 3 brings, and by a mile the most variety - Grifball, Zombie games etc

Graphics = Killzone 2
Sound = (Other shooters)
Controls = (Other shooters)
Gameplay = (Other shooters)
Multiplayer = (Other shooters)
Replayability = (Other shooters)

(Other shooters) = COD 4, COD 5, Halo 3, Gears of War 1&2, etc.

Verdict: Killzone 2 = 1 point, (Other shooters) = 5 points. Killzone 2 is decimated by competition already on the market. Killzone 2 is just like Crysis a generic shooter with top end visuals.

Since I own a PS3 and not a 360 I am going to have to go with Killzone 2.

Halo 3. Whilst I'm sure Killzone 2 is great come back in a years time when everyone is further away from the over the top hype.

Out of those 3 I prefer Killzone 2. And yes, I've played all of them.

for me Halo 3 is still my top game in this categorie but the others are amazing games too