Edge, a uk mag often considered as one of the best in the world has reviewed these games : (PS3) Heavenly Sword - 6 (X360) Bioshock - 8 (PS3) Warhawk - 8 (X360) MOH Airborne - 7 (X360) Stuntman Ignition - 6 (X360) Fatal Interia - 6 (X360) MotoGP 07 - 7 (DS) Heroes of Mana - 6 (XBLA) Space Giraffe - 8 (DS) Glory Days 2 - 4 (XBLA ) Wing Commander Arena - 4 So i would say quite bad for Heavenly sword, quite good for MoH (as the last ones were pretty bad) and maybe a little surprising for Bioshock and Warhawk, i dont doubt that Warhawk is good and deserves an 8 but its hard for me to believe that its as good as Bioshock. Sorry if it has already been posted.

Those were some unexpectedly poor scores. Especially Heavenly Sword and Heroes of Mana.

We are hearing more and more that HS's gameplay is lacking, as good as its graphics may be. The bioshock mark may be acceptable (it would be easily the lowest by a respectable reviewer), except that it gave it the same mark as warhawk. Ive just spent the last ten hours playing Bioshock and it is fast approaching the title of 'best game ive ever played', so for a multi player game, warhawk better be bloody fantastic.

Wow Edge sure is though in games ....

They gave Resistance a 6 and Gears a 7 some months back ....

A good score for Bioshock and Warhawk ,a 8 in Edge nearly assures its a high quality game .

As for Heavenly I dont care ,I have played it and know its good and will be getting it .Beat them up have to be the best of the generation to be midly well received by the reviewers ....

Edge are very strict with their ratings system... however it means you can trust their reviews more easily...

...and I don't think they have ever given a perfect score (10/10)

People seem to forget a 6 on Edge is a good game (probably 7-8 on most other places) so the HS score isn't bad.

The one that stands out is the Warhawk review. 8/10 for a multiplayer only game is really good. Alo, Space Giraffe getting 8/10 is great for a XBLA game.

I hate perfect score ...

Saiyar, when i say quite bad for Heavenly Sword, i mean quite bad towards high expectations most people have. It's right that a 6 is a good score in Edge and i think that Heavenly Sword is a good game (the demo is very short but fun) but its probably not the great killer ap people were expecting. Bye guys. :)