By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Gaming - Call of Duty 5 Beats Gears of War 2

Freeze!

 

It’s official. Call of Duty: World at War has sold more units on the Xbox 360 than Gears of War 2. The latest worldwide charts reveal that the latest offering in the famous war shooter series has managed to sell 4.34 million units since its release (and that's not including other formats), with it just now eclipsing the 4.30 million units of Gears of War 2 sold. A figure made all the more impressive given that Gears of War 2 released a week ahead of Call of Duty: WoW.

This gap will increase too, with Call of Duty: WoW consistently selling upwards of 50,000 more units a week more than Epic Games sci-fi shooter. And that success is translating to the online space as well, with Call of Duty: WoW the week’s most played Xbox Live game, beating out Halo, with Gears of War 2 coming in third just ahead, interestingly, of Call of Duty 4.

While both games have been a rousing success critically and financially, this result indicates an interesting shift in power, or at least presumed power, between exclusives and multi-format titles. We recently discussed this in-depth, running through the sales results for both the PS3 and the Xbox 360 to determine which was more dependent upon exclusives in terms of attach-rates and consumer trends. While you should check out that article for the full scoop, this would offer further proof that exclusives while important, aren’t the key contributor to the general bottom-line of a console’s success.

On a slightly different note, it offers some insights into the Xbox 360 consumer.

It would be hard to split which of the two brand names has more power within the Xbox community. The original Gears of War was the first blockbuster exclusive of this generation, while Call of Duty cemented itself as one of gaming’s premier franchises with 2007’s brilliant Modern Warfare. (check out the Top 50 Franchises of Next-Generation for more). But for all its media attention, and Microsoft support, Call of Duty is proving to be the more alluring purchase.

Does this indicate that gamers prefer first-person (CoD) to third-person (GoW), realistic worlds (CoD) to Sci-fi (GoW), nondescript heroes (CoD) to iconic characters (GoW)? Either way, it is worth noting that in the lead up to the launch of the two games, Call of Duty: WoW was the one facing the bigger uphill battle. It needed to hurdle two huge obstacles: the first being whether returning the series to the well-worn WWII era would be happily consumed by Modern Warfare’s fans. The second being whether stand-in developer Treyarch (who struggled to deliver compelling gameplay with Call of Duty 3) could provide an experience that would interest the series’ fans. Apparently the answer to both is yes, and yes.

We’ll monitor the charts to see how things evolve over the coming months as these two heavyweights battle for Xbox 360 supremacy. In the meantime, why not check out The Top 50 Xbox Characters of All Time, or our exclusive Cliffy B Tells All interview with Gears famous developer.



VGchartz stats links for both the games

http://www.vgchartz.com/games/game.php?id=23992



Around the Network

eh i think gears 2 deserves more...cod waw is just cod4 with a different atmosphere...



I dislike Cod5 especially since Cod4 is out.. but eh. to each his own.



 

 

COD:WaW may outsell Gears of War 2 in the short term but in the long term Gears of War 2 will outsell COD:WaW. By the time COD 6 is released COD:WaW will be long forgotten. Gears of War 2 will keep on selling and it will have long legs.
In terms of quality Gears of War 2 is a much better game than COD:WaW.

I would not buy COD:WaW because it is just another WW2 shooter.



numonex said:
[...]

I would not buy COD:WaW because it is just another WW2 shooter.

I'm sorry you feel that way. It's not just another WWII shooter, it's "teh" WWII shooter.



Random game thought :
Why is Bionic Commando Rearmed 2 getting so much hate? We finally get a real game and they're not even satisfied... I'm starting to hate the gaming community so f****** much...

Watch my insane gameplay videos on my YouTube page!

Around the Network

Both games are great but the single player and mp are clearly superior n Gears 2. COD5 MP is straight out of COD4 and the single player mode consists of very annoying American missions in Japan and very cool Russian mission in Germany. So its a hit and miss...

Gears 2 is the true blockbuster this holiday season, COD:WaW is filler till Moredn Warfare 2 comes out. Nevertheles...neither are struggling for sales thats for sure



Why do people act like cod waw is a small game. Call of duty is big now and I saw commercials every 5 seconds for it around Christmas(you are my enemy commercial) Call of duty waw was advertised alot. Do you really think microsoft cares if call of duty outsells gears of war 2 they care about you buying both on 360.



avqman said:
Why do people act like cod waw is a small game. Call of duty is big now and I saw commercials every 5 seconds for it around Christmas(you are my enemy commercial) Call of duty waw was advertised alot. Do you really think microsoft cares if call of duty outsells gears of war 2 they care about you buying both on 360.

 

 O yeah this man got it right!



Damn it must be late...I think I just read a forum post by red53devil lauding the software performance of the 360 (it's a beast!).

I think I'll go back to sleep and when I wake up, all will be normal again!



disolitude said:
Both games are great but the single player and mp are clearly superior n Gears 2.
COD5 MP is straight out of COD4 and the single player mode consists of very annoying American missions in Japan and very cool Russian mission in Germany. So its a hit and miss...

Gears 2 is the true blockbuster this holiday season, COD:WaW is filler till Moredn Warfare 2 comes out. Nevertheles...neither are struggling for sales thats for sure

 

Incorrect. Listen to game critics and fans alike talk about how they feel Gears 2 was rushed. How the multiplayer is essentially broken outside of Hoarde, (which is a lot of fun)

Yes COD WaW is very similar to COD4, but it does work.

Matchmaking, game lobbies, all of which are well chronicled to be somewhat broken on Gears 2.

The single player campaign in Gears 2 was good. but you could argue that it was Microsofts holiday "filler" till the next exclusive game is rushed. (by your logic)

I do however think Gears 2 is a better overall game. Slightly.



̶3̶R̶D̶   2ND! Place has never been so sweet.