Must you guys halo all over every thread ??? I like Halo a lot and am looking forward to play part 3 (still have to play part 2 though, never got around to play it), still I´m going to ceep my opinion about it to myself until I´ve played it, same thing should go for all the other unproven games, yes they will be great but lets argue about just how great until we know.
This however does not count for Mss Effect.... why ??? Its Bioshock...they ALWAYS deliver. The only question for me is can it beat the Baldurs Gate games for beeing my favorite game ever ??? Even if it doesn´t it will be great, I could easily wait till next year to get a 360 with all the great Wii games coming out this year but this game will make me get one as soon as I can get a Falcon.
From what I see the story will be more complex (in a good way) and player influenced than both KOTOR and BG1+2, the fighting seem to still be true AD&D rules but other than KOTOR you will do the fighting yourself and you get tactical elements like in R6:V, plus this is the first charackter dev. kit that impresses me, not like some where every face looks the same... or just plain ugly like in Oblivion.
And who gives a damn about what makes game of the year ??? there are so many great games from so many areas releasing this year that there will be more than enough for 5 games of the year, it´s just a stupid popularity contest like the oscars, winning or not winning this will not make a game better or worse, all this award will do is make some fanboys do geeky dances infront of their computers, so let it go already.