lol If you cant beat them...join them.

@Kantor, lol sorry man. back on track then. MGS4 deserves every bit of it.

As for Next years...will...All hell will break loose when those heavy hitters go head to head..

Nice stealth troll on R2.....R2 and Deadspace should be there, as well as the other ones you mentioned, Bioshock, NHL 09 and Braid should not be there.

1) What game do you think deserves to win?

LBP

2) What game do you think will win the Gamespot GoTY?

MGS4

3) What game do you think will win User GoTY?

MGS4

4) What games are in there that shouldn't be?

Braid, BioShock, NHL09

5) What games aren't in there that should be?

Gears of War 2, GoWCoO, L4D, Fable 2, Prince of Persia, CoD WaW, FFVIICC

6) What five games next year do you think will be contenders for GoTY?

Real tough question, we don't know exactly what's going to be released and we haven't seen enough gameplay videos of the games that will be released, so I'm only putting games where we have gameplay videos.

Killzone 2, Resident Evil 5, Gran Turismo 5, Star Ocean 4, inFramous

1) What game do you think deserves to win?

LBP

2) What game do you think will win the Gamespot GoTY?

MGS4 (my second choice for #1)

3) What game do you think will win User GoTY?

MGS4

4) What games are in there that shouldn't be?

NHL 09, Braid, Bioshock

5) What games aren't in there that should be?

Left 4 Dead, Valkyria Chronicles, Gears of War 2, Fable II, Prince of Persia

6) What five games next year do you think will be contenders for GoTY?

Zelda Wii (firm believer that it WILL be out next year :P), God of War III, Killzone 2, Call of Duty 6, and Uncharted 2 (I wish)

With all my heart, I wish you are right. lol

And Nintendo likes to announce games at the last minute lately.  Just look at Mario Kart Wii.  :)

1. LittleBigPlanet
2. Metal Gears Solid 4
3. MGS4
4. GTA IV, Resi 2, NHL 09, Bioshock
5. World of Goo, The World Ends With You, No More Heroes, Prince of Persia
6. God of War 3, Alan Wake, Some Nintendo Game We don't Know Yet, MadWorld, Resident Evil 5

Don't tell me, I remember the times I was a big Nintendo fan......all the way up to the NGC era I always favored (and suffered) with the Big N. I would also expect a F Zero Wii next year if I had a Wii.

1) What game do you think deserves to win?

Unfortunately I haven't played them all (saving MGS for later), but from what I've played, SSBB.

2) What game do you think will win the Gamespot GoTY?

MGS4? I don't really know Gamespot.

3) What game do you think will win User GoTY?

MGS4.

4) What games are in there that shouldn't be?

NHL09(?), Bioshock, Resistance 2 - GTFO. Sorry, I have a thing against Resistance xP

5) What games aren't in there that should be?

Gears of War 2? Amazed R2 made it there when GeoW2 didn't...

6) What five games next year do you think will be contenders for GoTY?

It's nearly impossible to tell at this point. Microsoft and Nintendo (and possibly Sony) have been holding their cards, who knows what they'll surprise us with.

edit: Noticed Zucas mentioned TWEWY, do they include handhelds for this stuff?