NOTE TO MODS AND FANBOYS: THIS THREAD IS NOT CREATED TO INCITE ANGER, IT IS ONLY TO KNOW WHICH GAME IS BETTER FOR SOMEONE WHO HAS MUTLIPLE CONSOLES!!!
Okay, I know that I'm not the only one around here with more than one system, and I'm sure that many of you have had to make choices on which system to get your multiplatform games for, so... I've decided to make this thread.
Below is a table, listing the Name of the game, the Available systems (Wii, 360, and PS3. Portables and PS2 don't count) The Major Benefits/Problems of going with each version, and the determined best system, or if it close enough, It can be listed as PP (Personal Preference), and the winners, if any, can be listed.
For example, The 360 version of Madden '08 (not '09) was obviously superior to the PS3 version, but it is a matter of taste between graphics and Control to determine which is better between the 360 and Wii version, so the last column would say "PP: 1. Wii60," followed by "2. PS3" on another space down
And for the record, Quality of online play (service, not game types) is out of the window, with the exception of Wii-PS3 comparisons, because for the 360's better online play, you have to pay for it, while PSN is free...
If the game is finished, the title will be highlighted in Green Gray. If not, It will be highlighted in Red. The title bar is highlighted in Yellow. If 2 versions of a game are similar enough (nearl identical), they will be listed as one (ex: PS360).
I will start this thread with Guitar Hero: World Tour. I will update the OP as much as possible (probably every 2 days on average)
Your contributions will be greatly appreciated!!!
Oh, and Best >>> Better
Make sure to check symbols at the bottom, such as PP, *, $$$, IPAF, and ATM
Game |
Avail. |
Wii |
360 |
PS3 |
Verdict |
Guitar Hero: |
Wii |
- Guitar Vibrations via Wiimote, |
- Completely Compatible Instruments, |
- Partially Compatible Instruments, |
1. 360 |
Rock Band
|
Wii
|
- No Band World Tour Mode |
- Completely Compatible Instruments |
Pretty much the same as the XBOX 360 |
1. PS360 |
Fallout 3
|
360
|
N/A |
- DLC will be available |
- Aliasing issues
|
1. 360 |
Call Of Duty: World At War |
Wii |
- $10 cheaper |
- Best |
- Aliasing Problems
|
PP*: |
Far Cry 2 |
360 |
N/A |
- Runs smoother |
- A few more graphical hitches
|
1. 360
|
Mirror's Edge |
360 |
N/A |
- Less graphical hitches
|
- Motion controls |
1. PS3 |
Guitar Hero |
Wii |
- Guitar Vibrations via Wiimote,
|
- DLC |
Pretty much the same |
1. PS360 |
Sonic Unleashed |
Wii |
- Exclusive Better-implemented Drift Mechanics - Good Motion Controls (daytime) - 6 Bonus Acts not in the HD Version |
- Achievements |
- Trophies
|
1. Wii
|
BioSHOCK |
360 |
|
-Graphics are almost
|
- Bonus Difficulty level
|
$$$
|
Grand Theft |
360 |
N/A |
- Exclusive DLC |
- Less Glitches, Framerate Issues |
1. 360 |
Call of Duty 4: |
360 |
N/A |
- Achievements |
- Slightly deeper contrast |
PP: PS360 |
Tomb Raider: |
Wii |
- $30 |
- $50 |
- $50 |
1. 360 |
Assassin's Creed
|
360
|
N/A
|
- Achievements
|
- Framerate
|
1. 360 |
The Orange Box |
360 |
N/A |
- Better Frame Rate |
- Quick save feature |
1. 360 |
Rock Band 2 |
Wii |
- Worst Graphics |
- 1080p Resolution |
- 720p Resolution |
1. 360 |
Prototype |
360 |
N/A |
- Slightly more detailed character models. |
- Better contrast, world looks more vivid |
IPAF, PP. ATM: |
PP |
= Personal Preference |
||||
* |
= Are controls more important to you, or are graphics? |
||||
$$$ |
= Price due to age is a major deciding factor. It may make you decide differently than the verdict. Price will go down eventually, and then the original ruling will definitely apply |
||||
IPAF |
= If problems are fixed (Install issues, ect.), this verdict will change. Reat other notes. |
||||
ATM |
At the moment (Current standings, regardless of other circumstances listed)… |
NOTE TO MODS AND FANBOYS: THIS THREAD IS NOT CREATED TO INCITE ANGER, IT IS ONLY TO KNOW WHICH GAME IS BETTER FOR SOMEONE WHO HAS MUTLIPLE CONSOLES!!!
Okay, I know that I'm not the only one around here with more than one system, and I'm sure that many of you have had to make choices on which system to get your multiplatform games for, so... I've decided to make this thread.
Below is a table, listing the Name of the game, the Available systems (Wii, 360, and PS3. Portables and PS2 don't count) The Major Benefits/Problems of going with each version, and the determined best system, or if it close enough, It can be listed as PP (Personal Preference), and the winners, if any, can be listed.
For example, The 360 version of Madden '08 (not '09) was obviously superior to the PS3 version, but it is a matter of taste between graphics and Control to determine which is better between the 360 and Wii version, so the last column would say "PP: 1. Wii60," followed by "2. PS3" on another space down
And for the record, Quality of online play (service, not game types) is out of the window, with the exception of Wii-PS3 comparisons, because for the 360's better online play, you have to pay for it, while PSN is free...
If the game is finished, the title will be highlighted in Green Gray. If not, It will be highlighted in Red. The title bar is highlighted in Yellow. If 2 versions of a game are similar enough (nearl identical), they will be listed as one (ex: PS360).
I will start this thread with Guitar Hero: World Tour. I will update the OP as much as possible (probably every 2 days on average)
Your contributions will be greatly appreciated!!!
Oh, and Best >>> Better
Make sure to check symbols at the bottom, such as PP, *, and $$$
Game |
Avail. |
Wii |
360 |
PS3 |
Verdict |
Guitar Hero: |
Wii |
- Guitar Vibrations via Wiimote, |
- Completely Compatible Instruments, |
- Partially Compatible Instruments, |
1. 360 |
Rock Band
|
Wii
|
- No Band World Tour Mode |
- Completely Compatible Instruments |
Pretty much the same as the XBOX 360 |
1. PS360 |
Fallout 3
|
360
|
N/A |
- DLC will be available |
- Aliasing issues
|
1. 360 |
Call Of Duty: World At War |
Wii |
- $10 cheaper |
- Best |
- Aliasing Problems
|
PP*: |
Far Cry 2 |
360 |
N/A |
- Runs smoother |
- A few more graphical hitches
|
1. 360
|
Mirror's Edge |
360 |
N/A |
- Less graphical hitches
|
- Motion controls |
1. PS3 |
Guitar Hero |
Wii |
- Guitar Vibrations via Wiimote,
|
- DLC |
Pretty much the same |
1. PS360 |
Sonic Unleashed |
Wii |
- Exclusive Better-implemented Drift Mechanics - Good Motion Controls (daytime) - 6 Bonus Acts not in the HD Version |
- Achievements |
- Trophies
|
1. Wii
|
BioSHOCK |
360 |
|
-Graphics are almost
|
- Bonus Difficulty level
|
$$$
|
Grand Theft |
360 |
N/A |
- Exclusive DLC |
- Less Glitches, Framerate Issues |
1. 360 |
Call of Duty 4: |
360 |
N/A |
- Achievements |
- Slightly deeper contrast |
PP: PS360 |
Tomb Raider: |
Wii |
- $30 |
- $50 |
- $50 |
1. 360 |
Assassin's Creed
|
360
|
N/A
|
- Achievements
|
- Framerate
|
1. 360 |
The Orange Box |
360 |
N/A |
- Better Frame Rate |
- Quick save feature |
1. 360 |
PP |
= Personal Preference |
||||
* |
= Are controls more important to you, or are graphics? |
||||
$$$ |
= Price due to age is a major deciding factor. It may make you decide differently than the verdict. Price will go down eventually, and then the original ruling will definitely apply |