Both MGS4 and LBP are amazing games but just curious.........are you going off of
Metacritic, or Game Rankings. On Game Rankings MGS4 has a 92.5% (92%) and Gears 2 (currently) has a 93.6%(94%). Gears 2 still has more reviews yet to be posted, this of course could bring it up or down accordingly. So technically, depending on your source, LBP and Gears 2 are the two highest rated exclusives so far this Gen (on the HD consoles)!

http://www.gamerankings.com/htmlpages2/926596.asp?q=MGS4

http://www.gamerankings.com/htmlpages2/938611.asp

Others will of course post other links, that will be refuted or back up your post accordingly.

i hate gameranking i use meta because they weigh more on some reviews that are more reliable my only probelm with meta is they based a grade on review they read that pisses me off.

I kinda feel like trolling too!!

If you remove the extremely overrated GTAIV from game rankings 3/4 of the top 4 games are from Nintendo.

Just stating some facts....

This is what we like to call flamebait. Yes, it is fact but it is also flamebait and not so much tolerated (in fact, pretty sure you've been warned for it-- lets checked).

         Hmmmm, you use the site that backs up your claim.......shocker.....but fair enough.  But I could turn around and say "I hate metacritc, i use game rankings because they weigh more on some review that are more reliably, my only problem with game rankings is they base there reviews off of sites that actually give scores...../sarcasim"  See, I can do it too.....;)

Gears of war 1 and halo 3 are all rated higher than MGS4 at gamerankings. Which I think is a better source. So fact GoW1 and halo 3 are both better than MGS4. In fact even looking at metacritic GoW and Halo 3 have the same score as MGS4.

LBP and GoW2 aren't worth looking at yet as all the reviews aren't in.