Best is subjective.... is best a measure of fun, time spent, quality or is it an overall experience thing?

Because for the first two it's Mario Kart Wii for me easily, for the third it's Metroid Prime 3 or Super Mario Galaxy.... I don't really know which of these two to pick for the combination of the three things.

Super Mario Galaxy. What a game!!!

I would have to say Super Mario Galaxy (currently trying to beat with Luigi) because it is just so well thought out. Then Mario Kart and Metroid Prime are right up there after that.

Super Mario Galaxy or Metroid Prime 3.

Those are the two games I wasn't disappointed in playing on the Wii:
- TP is really OoT + new graphics + waggle
- Brawl was more melee than original and I really disliked Melee
- Mario Kart Wii: I had high expectations after Mario Kart DS, it let me down

They are far from being bad games, but I guess you could say my disappointment is a sign of how highly I regard most of Nintendos work.

So hard to pick one - Single Player - Fire Emblem or Tomb Raider for me

Multiplayer - Brawl or Mario Kart or Wii Sports (depends who I'm playing with)

COD: WAW to me, yeah Im the only one who is different here cant wait to buy that game not now though, I think till the price comes lower...

Fire Emblem: Radiant Dawn

Brawl is amazing, i can't really decide which is the best Wii game, so many great games, but SSBB is awesome, especially if you play online (with no lag that is)

Super Mario Galaxy
Super Smash Bros. Brawl
Metroid Prime 3
Mario Kart Wii

I can't choose, they are all equally good. Bar Portal, easily the 4 most enjoyable games this generation.

First party -- Super Mario Galaxy
Third party -- Boom Blox

Mike from Morgantown