AC will have the lowest launch. But lifetime sales will be between AC and GoW2.

Gears will be fronloaded sales!!! Massive slaes mostly at the begning, both AC and LBP will both have better legs

lifetime sales:
1. Animal Crossing
2. Gears of War
[..]
Resistance 2

scores:
well, come on even if gow2 and r2 turn out to be "worst game evah" and animal crossing most revolutionary game since forever gow2 and r2 would still score higher thanks to hypewagon.
if it comes to the scores wii games always suffers because they're on nintendo console and never gonna receive scores they deserve.

If resistance 2 outsells gears 2 ill cut my penis off and mail it to you OP.

I'd like to know how his logic is flawed.

I don't see the logic in saying that a game on a handheld, moving back to console, is somehow going to be hindered. Where is the logic in that? Any facts to back that up?

Mariokart Wii is in fact, a GREAT example of smacking that down.