Hey, at least we didn't had to give that page free hits for checking the list, right?

The GC controller is almost perfect, but it fails hardly at one thing: It's sticks tend to screw a lot. All of my five GC controllers have their sticks faulty.

The Dual Shock... geez I hate the Dual Shock. It makes my wrists hurt, plus the sticks feel a bit loose. Not to mention the D-Pad. Why is it divided? It makes me get blisters.

The 360 is a really good pad, pretty much perfected the "old" controller type.

The Wii Mote is great, gotta love the IR and the motion controllers, it's very comfortable, but it's D-Pad it's a bit hard on the thumb.

And seriously, no mention of Keyboard + Mouse while you add the Steel Battalion, GH and Guncon? Crap list and site.

/endofrant

The dual shock should be nr 1.. any of the dual shocks..

Dual shocks ftw.  :P only controllers this gen that are wireless and doesn't require you to insert batteries.

If you're referring to comfort alone, it would have to be keyboard + mouse, and then 360, with neither the Dualshock or Wiimote and none of them are particularly ergonomic, though the Dualshock > Wiimote for comfort.

However saying the 360 controller is the 'best' is just stupid, it doesnt even come with a rechargable battery :p and doesn't feature motion control!

However, the G25 should be no. 1, even if it's excluded for just dring games :P

Unlike some others, I must agree with #1. The first time I picked up the 360's controller I thought "Wow... Perfect."

I'm not saying that as a fanboy, I'm saying that as my honest, genuine response. The size, the weight, the setup, it was perfect. I still feel that way today.