Definate top 10:
360 - Gears 2
PS3 - Resistance 2, LBP, PES 2009
Wii - Animal Crossing

Possible top 10:
360 - COD: World at War, Fallout 3
PS3 - COD: World at War, Fallout 3
Wii - Wii Music

Other big launches that will not make it.
Fable II, Banjo, Motorstorm: Pacific Rift, GH4, 007 QoS, Left 4 Dead, Prince of Persia, Dead Space, WKC

360: Gears 2
PS3: Resistance 2 , PES 2009, Motorstorm 2, LBP

Halo rules them all.

Although it makes me unhappy in my pants, I think I have to agree with you on those.

But why do you think Fable 2 won't cut the mustard?

How many non-shooters or Madden are in the 360 top ten?

hmm...an excelent point...

Anyone notice that the 360 top ten is made up almost full of Shooters and Madden? That says a lot for it's target demographic. While PS3 and Wii owners have more diverse top ten lists?

Pokemon Diamond/Pearl on the DS came very, very close to dethroning Halo3 for first week sales.  Just 250k short.

A Very interesting list which tells a lot for each system. The PS3 list will no doubt change the most over the next Year, i would also imagine the only title to have a chance to dethrone GTA4 would be GTA5 or GT5 if they can get a really good damage system and do enough to spice of the game.

I can't see any wii game beating brawl, but if the next Zelda pulls an OoT it will have a chance to make a pretty high place. But Animal Crossing should make the list this fall.

For the 360 there is only one title that could ever dethrone Halo3 and that's Halo4. Gears2 will pull into third place this fall and Madden2010 and CoD6 will make nice editions to the list in 2009. I'm not sure where GTA5 will fit in since R* said its impossible to fit it on the 360 DVD, and i'm not sure how a GTA game would work on two discs unless its a launch game for the 720.