|
Appoles said: many ancient kingdoms didn't like to record military failures and the like Timmah! said: what great interest did these other nations have of recording the history of their neighbors |
Timmah:
Its obvious from looking at history that ancient people were interested in their neighbors. In ancient times, similar to today's times, leaders and the general population were greatly interested in what was going on in the rest of the world. People would gather to hear travelers and traders tell their stories, leaders would request information from the affairs of other nations. Not only was this of interest for entertainment purposes, but it was also of interest for defense purposes. If your neighbor was invaded by an army you want to know who these invaders are, what their intentions are, and what their charactersistics are, just in case your next (or if you plan on doing some conquering yourself).
Simple familiarization with historical records makes it obvious that the ancients knew and sought information about the world around them.
Appolse:
Very true, ancient people, just like people today, liked to make events more favorable to them. In many cases (such as Egypt and the Hittites draw and eventual peace treaty) both sides claimed victory. The Egyptians mentioned eliminating a Hittite chariot unit forced the Hittite to accept peace while the Hittites said a chariot unit's bravery scared the Egyptians into accepting peace.
However, these events were recorded and it was in great interest for other nations to record information that was detremental to their competitors, not to mention fantastical stories. We have countless stories from ancient story tellers on perhaps-truthful events (Atlantis and the Trojan War are prime examples), and an actual event that made the Nile run red and killed over a hundred thousand Egyptian children would have been heavily told in stories and kept in records. Historians would be stumbling over details of the story in historical records and archeological finds.
But there are no records. The many traders and travelers to and from Egypt didn't spread the story, the Egyptians didn't keep the story in any form. It doesnt take much to think that this story was a huge fabrication from the Hebrews.
Thats not to mention that the Egyptians kept great records, even of events that they didn't like. Ahmotep, for example, was hated throughout all of Egypt (he changed the religion and fired the priest class) and everything he did in his rule was destroyed after his death, but there are still countless records of him.












