They are all not that great compared to Zelda: A link to the past...

OoT >> Tp = Okami > SotC

All four are in my top ten of all time, though. :D

I haven't played SotC, so I will abstain. I do love this thread though.

Ocariona, then Shadow of the Colosuss. Okami and Twillight Princes are equal.

Tp>Okami>Sotc>>>Oot All excellent games though.

i ´ve only played occarina, so I can´t vote, but you could include the best games of all consoles, like DKC for SNes.
well I didn´t have a lot of plataforms... :(

I've played OoT many times and I beat TP. I played Okami a bit...but..I got sorta bored. And, well, I didn't have a PS2 so I can't say anything about SotC. But, Out of the three I've played, OoT definitely wins.

OoT is fantastic, near flawless.

Shadow of the Colossus, but only because I really don't like Zelda, and I already spoke my piece on Okami (it can go to hell).

My vote for best game ever is Operation: Flashpoint. Hardest of hardcore shooters, first game to give a huge battlefield and still does it better than any game before it. Also it was so hyper-realistic that quite a few armed forces, civilian forces, and special forces use it for training. (called VBS-1).

I'm pretty sure he's focusing on action/adventure titles.