I thought you were making fun of my post. I thought you were saying that you cant know for sure but you can take a guess.

its not bad.....everyone is talking about 10 milion sold like it's a failure....honestly, how many games have sold 10 million?

wow.. its gone ahead of CoD4 360+ps3 sales (which according to vgchartz is sitting at 9.9mil), is this the top selling multiplatform game so far this gen? (pc versions excluded, since we don't have the data)

EDIT: nvm, i answered my own question - guitar hero 3 is on around 13mil

my guess is around 13 million combined LTD.

Quite a few, now how many games deserved to sell 10 million, i know GTA 4 isn't on my list heh.

 Yes, but I'm sure its on 10 million other peoples.

Surprised nobody has brought it up, but this is sold to consumer not shipped.  The Kotaku article didn't seem very clear on that matter.

If I remember correctly they had it around 8.5 million at the start of June.  So about 1.5 million sold in the last two and a half months.  Big drop, but still selling decently.

Maybe GTAIV doesn't have great legs...but it got amazing first week sales which is a great feat! Now the next target is 15 Mil.