I'm not saying that the reviewer was biased reviewing Too Human, but if I was 1up I probably would of picked someone who didn't just come from the Official Playstation Magazine...

http://www.1up.com/do/my1Up?publicUserId=5380090

"On a personal note, it feels great to be back at Ziff/1up/EGM. As some of you may or may not know, I used to be one of the crazy people at the Official PlayStation Magazine " - Giancarlo Varanini

Its things like this that start crazy conspiracy theories where fanboys start saying that Sony paid 1up to get a PS3 fanboy to review the game...

So what if the lowest ranking on metacritic is from a reviewer that has blogged about the PS3 since 2006...

Thread title:

im·pli·ca·tion

n.

1. The act of implicating or the condition of being implicated.
2. The act of implying or the condition of being implied.
3. Something that is implied, especially:
   1. An indirect indication; a suggestion.
   2. An implied meaning; implicit significance.
   3. An inference. See Usage Note at infer.

Who cares?

It's not like they got a PS3 fanboy to review Gears of War 2 or something.

This is Too Human we're talking about, it was going to get a low score either way.

That's true, there could be some crazy conspiracy where Sony paid 1up to let this guy be the one to review Too Human. Or the game could just be a disappointment. Considering that 1up is the lowest, but it certainly isn't totally against the other reviews I've seen, I'm leaning towards the second option.

Yup must be a conspiracy since it's Sony.

The game is far from a C-...its a much better gaming experinece.

But I don't think Sony would worry too much about too human to start conspiring against it.

I think what we got here is someone who either didn't give the game a fair shake, or in general doesn't like action RPgs.

It's not like they're the only that thrashed Too Human...

What next ?

You're going to claim that Sony bribed the official X-Box magazine to give the game a 65 lol ?

or Team-Xbox (65)?
or XBox World 360 Magazine Uk (68)

Darn Sony is far reaching !!!

Gebx.

I spend 24 hours trying to convince the whole site that Too Human turning out to be a steaming pile of dung isn't a bitter disappointment and then you go and make a thread CLEARLY showing everyone just how bitter us Xbox 360 fans really are.

Sigh.

The game wasn't hyped much at all, but I did so badly want it to be awesome.

 1ups score is not the lowest review score.

http://www.gamerankings.com/htmlpages4/928546.asp

GameSpot		8/18/2008	5.5 out of 10	55.0%
GameSpy		8/19/2008	2.5 out of 5	50.0%
GameDaily		8/19/2008	5 out of 10	50.0%

Actually that is not the lowest though tied for one of the lowest.

Giant Bomb 8/19/2008 3 out of 5 60.0%
Worth Playing 8/19/2008 6 out of 10 60.0%
Eurogamer 8/19/2008 6 out of 10 60.0%
1UP 8/18/2008 C- 60.0%
GameSpot 8/18/2008 5.5 out of 10 55.0%
GameSpy 8/19/2008 2.5 out of 5 50.0%
GameDaily 8/19/2008 5 out of 10 50.0%

Also some magazine gave it a 40% but can't remember the name.