By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - General - (Olympic Swimming) Is the use of Racing Bodysuits ethical?

VS

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/LZR_Racer                                     

From http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Swimsuit#Competitive_swimwear:

"

Competitive swimwear

Unlike regular swimsuits, which are designed mainly for the physical appearances, competitive swimwear is manufactured for the purpose of aiding athletes in swim competitions. They reduce friction and drag in the water, increasing the efficiency of the swimmer's forward motion. The tight fits allow for easy movement and are said to reduce muscle vibration,[2] thus reducing drag. Starting around 2000, in an effort to improve the effectiveness of the swimsuits, engineers have taken to designing them to replicate the skin of sea based animals, sharks in particular.[3]

These swim suits are created in order to make water resistance as minimal as possible and thus allowing a swimmer to move more efficiently in water. The company Speedo, for example, came out with a swimsuit called “Fastskin”. It was discovered by scientists studying sharkskin that human skin is inadequate at “slicing” the water because of its porous design.[4] Sharkskin is made of scales spaced very closely together called dermal denticles. It is the grooves in between the scales that produce drag resistant skin.[5] The ridges allow water to pass around the shark more efficiently. More recently, Speedo launched a new swimsuit called "Fastskin LZR RACER". Scientists carried out a global 3D body scanning exercise involving some 400 athletes to discover more about the precise shape of their bodies. Using Computational fluid dynamics, which can predict how existing and new product designs will behave in real-world environments, was used to evaluate the friction, pressure and fluid flow characteristics around swimmers. This analysis indicated where most drag occurs on the swimmer’s body, allowing Speedo to design for optimal drag reduction."

The racing suits not only reduce drag, but the newest models models also support and guide muscle movement (from what I understand) and therefore decrease th amount of effort required to swim faster. The problem in my eyes is that they have made it much too easy for world records set with traditional suits to stand the test of time. So many swimming world records have been broken and rebroken since the racing suits have been permitted in international competition.

As long as all athletes have acces to these suits (IE: that certain countries don't have acces to the due to other countries having exclusivity contracts I'm not aware of), I see no problem with them, since everyone has acces to the same competitive advantage. One thing I would like to see though is a distinction between old style suit records and racing suit records.

What do you think?



Around the Network

It's fine with me. Records never seem to account for rule changes.

Nobody said anything when the 3-point line was added in basketball, or when Football added games on to the regular season or when Baseball added the DH. (Which prolonges a hitters life in the MLB)

Or the various other sports that have had rule changes that greatly changed the game... like the wussification of hockey.



It's one of those things which is very hard to draw a line on... At what point does it become too much? How to quantify those qualitative statements such as "reduces muscle vibration"?

Regarding the records, it's not a big deal, although it does render them somewhat useless. Doesn't the same happen in track and field due to new shoes?

Not all the athletes have the resources to get the best suits, but money plays a big part in other parts of the athletes' training, so I guess we can lump this all together under the "resources problem", if we want to call it a problem of course. A big part of a country's results in the Olympics is how much money and help the athletes are given.

The bottom line for me is that for most sports, it's not an equal competition between all the participants... but I watch it for entertainment, so it's fine by me.

 



My Mario Kart Wii friend code: 2707-1866-0957

Good points about the shoes, NJ5. I propose naked and shoeless Olympics. Beachvolleyball and wrestling ratings will skyrocket, weightlifting's not so much.



Did you just use this as excuse to post a pic of a dude in speedos?



Around the Network
Mistershine said:
Did you just use this as excuse to post a pic of a dude in speedos?

 

LOL....



SSBB FC: 5155 2671 4071 elgefe02: "VGChartz's Resident Raving Rabbit"   MKWii:5155-3729-0989

No. I tried to find a decent pic of just the briefs, but gave up and just used the pics from http://www.speedo.com/webapp/wcs/stores/servlet//Category3_10151_10202_33384_33311_-1



Mistershine said:
Did you just use this as excuse to post a pic of a dude in speedos?

 

LMFAO... but yeah.. you could have at least post pictures of the swimming ladies...



 

Face the future.. Gamecenter ID: nikkom_nl (oh no he didn't!!) 

It's because the original examples are much more dramatic in turms of additional coverage than going from this

  to

 



Imagine someone made a suit which contained energy in some form which helped propel the swimmers. Would that be illegal under the current rules? That's clearly the kind of thing which shouldn't be allowed, yet I'm not sure of how far the current suits are from that.



My Mario Kart Wii friend code: 2707-1866-0957